Committee Reverses Minister's Bid to Hide Report

Portfolio Committee on Public Works and Infrastructure will hear the Telkom Towers forensic report in an open meeting.

Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Politics

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a tall columned government building with open doors and a flagpole, in deep red, cream, and navy, evoking open parliamentary oversight.
Parliament's Portfolio Committee on Public Works and Infrastructure reversed Minister Dean Macpherson's bid to present the Telkom Towers forensic report in closed session, ruling it must be heard in an open meeting. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you trust the federal government to be open about its investigations?

The Portfolio Committee on Public Works and Infrastructure has reversed the Minister's decision to hear the Telkom Towers forensic report behind closed doors. The report, prepared by Gobodo Forensic and Investigative Accounting, must be presented in an open meeting, according to Parliament's legal services.

Why it matters

The ruling affirms that Parliament's legal advice, not a ministerial request, determines whether a committee sits in camera, which bears on oversight of public works spending across South Africa. The Minister had earlier refused to give the committee the report, arguing it was materially insufficient and contained sensitive information.

Parliament's legal services found the report did not provide reasonable grounds for an in camera hearing and advised that it must be presented in an open meeting. The committee has resolved to schedule a further meeting, but the date has not been set.

The players

Dean Macpherson

Minister of Public Works and Infrastructure who had refused to give the committee the Telkom Towers report and sought to present it behind closed doors.

Gobodo Forensic and Investigative Accounting

Forensic accounting firm that prepared the Telkom Towers forensic report under review by Parliament.

The details

The committee debated a request from Minister of Public Works and Infrastructure Dean Macpherson to present the report in camera. Committee members objected to the Minister presenting the report while the accounting officer was present, and the Minister said he would present it himself because the Director-General was hesitant to do so. The Minister had argued that presenting the report could expose Parliament and his department's officials to legal challenges and cited real threats to officials in his department.

Timeline

  1. 19 November 2026: Committee reverses the Minister's decision to hear the report in camera.

Political Context

The ministerial push for a closed-door hearing runs against the committee's oversight role, which depends on open scrutiny of public works and infrastructure spending. Dissent from committee members centred on the Minister presenting the report while the accounting officer was absent from the presentation.

The decision means the Telkom Towers findings will be discussed in public, giving citizens and the media access to the committee's deliberations. Any contents of the report that touch on public funds will be examined openly rather than held back by the executive.

The takeaway

Parliamentary oversight holds when committees insist on open hearings, even against a minister's objections. Readers following public works spending can track the rescheduled meeting for the report's findings.

What happens next

The committee resolved to schedule another meeting to consider the report and to write to the Portfolio Committee on Police to explore a joint meeting on it.

Further reading

Explore more on Government coverage for the wider parliamentary oversight context in South Africa.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Parliament.

Live Poll

Do you trust the federal government to be open about its investigations?