Johannes Mudau Criticises Mamelodi Sundowns Market Dominance

Former star Johannes Mudau highlights how club spending practices disrupt the balance of the South African PSL.

Updated on Oct. 25, 2026 in Soccer

Expressive sports illustration of a soccer match in progress, featuring abstract players in yellow and green jerseys, capturing intense athletic motion. — Former star Johannes Mudau says Mamelodi Sundowns’ aggressive transfer spending creates financial disparities and disrupts competitive balance within the South African Premier Soccer League. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Does heavy spending by top teams negatively impact the competitiveness of your local sports league?

Johannes Mudau claims Mamelodi Sundowns has created significant financial disparities within the Premier Soccer League through aggressive transfer strategies. By maintaining a vast roster, the club is accused of securing talent to dominate the league, often leaving signed players on the bench.

Why it matters

The concentration of talent at a single club risks destabilising the competitive balance of professional football in South Africa. This trend forces smaller teams to navigate a market where prices are increasingly disconnected from traditional valuations.

Mamelodi Sundowns maintains a massive squad of 77 players. Recent negotiations saw a R4 million offer for Seluleko Mahlambi rejected, with TS Galaxy FC demanding R10 million for the player.

The players

Johannes Mudau

A former professional footballer who played for both Mamelodi Sundowns and Kaizer Chiefs during his career.

Mamelodi Sundowns

A prominent South African football club competing in the Premier Soccer League.

Kaizer Chiefs

One of the most successful and supported professional football clubs in South Africa.

Tim Sukazi

The chairman of TS Galaxy FC who has been active in public commentary regarding transfer market valuations.

Seluleko Mahlambi

A professional footballer currently at the centre of transfer negotiations between league clubs.

The details

Mamelodi Sundowns is accused of recruiting talent regardless of price, effectively removing depth from rival squads. This practice was recently highlighted when TS Galaxy FC chairman Tim Sukazi declined a R4 million bid from Kaizer Chiefs for Seluleko Mahlambi, insisting on a R10 million valuation.

25 October 2026: Article publication date.

Season Trajectory

This concentration of talent impacts the broader league competitiveness by thinning the available player pool for other clubs. Such squad sizes shift the season trajectory, as Mamelodi Sundowns creates a financial gap that challenges the historical parity of the PSL.

The disparity in squad sizes significantly limits the player movement options available to other clubs, directly impacting the talent depth of the entire league. This creates a challenging environment where smaller teams struggle to secure competitive transfer fees for their assets.

The takeaway

The accumulation of excessive talent at the top of the league can diminish overall competitive interest for supporters of smaller clubs. Developing a more sustainable youth pipeline or league-wide salary caps may eventually be required to ensure long-term stability.