Retrial Set for Cheyenne Man in Shooting Case
A judge has tentatively scheduled a new jury trial after a November mistrial in an attempted second-degree murder case.
Updated on Nov. 13, 2026 in Crime

Judge Nathaniel Hibben has tentatively scheduled a retrial for the week of Dec. 14 for a Cheyenne man accused of attempted second-degree murder in the April 30 shooting of Matthew Kerlee. A jury declared a mistrial on Nov. 6 after more than 12 hours of deliberation.
Why it matters
The mistrial means the case will go before a new jury, and the defendant, who faces up to life in prison if convicted, remains in custody. The case also raises questions about how Wyoming's speedy-trial rules apply to retrials, which the rule does not address.
The defendant has been held for 197 days on a felony attempted second-degree murder charge, with a retrial tentatively set for the week of Dec. 14 following the Nov. 6 mistrial. The gun used in the shooting has not been recovered, and the final date of the new trial has not been confirmed.
The players
Judge Nathaniel Hibben
Judge Hibben presides over the case in Wyoming's courts and set the tentative date for the retrial.
The details
The shooting occurred around 4:10 a.m. on April 30, when two shots were fired and one struck Matthew Kerlee in the chest; Kerlee was taken to Cheyenne Medical Regional Center for emergency surgery. The defense argues self-defense, citing threats allegedly made by a former partner of the defendant, and the defendant fled before law enforcement arrived. Two women, Brianna Parry and Hailey Scheschi, called 911 after allegedly finding Kerlee on the ground.
Timeline
April 19: The defense says threats against the defendant began.
April 30, around 4:10 a.m.: Two shots were fired, striking Kerlee in the chest.
Nov. 3: The jury trial began.
Nov. 6: A mistrial was declared after more than 12 hours of deliberation.
Week of Dec. 14: A new jury trial is tentatively scheduled.
Legal Context
Wyoming Rule 48, which sets speedy-trial requirements, does not address retrials after a mistrial, leaving timing questions open in cases like this one. The retrial scheduled for December illustrates how mistrials can extend the time a defendant spends in custody before a verdict.
Residents of Cheyenne may be affected by the ongoing case through the court calendar and local safety concerns tied to a shooting. The retrial timing could affect witnesses and local attendance at court proceedings.
The takeaway
Mistrials can extend the wait for resolution, and the outcome of the December retrial will determine the next stage of this case. Readers following local criminal cases can track court calendars for updates on the new trial date.
What happens next
A new jury trial is tentatively scheduled for the week of Dec. 14, and the date is expected to be confirmed by the court.
Further reading
For more on how cases like this move through the system, see Criminal Justice coverage from Cheyenne.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Wyoming Tribune Eagle.






