Appeals Court Upholds Insurer Denial of TCT Defense
A federal appeals panel ruled that TCT's former insurer owes no defense costs in a 2015 class action tied to the company's conversion to for-profit status.
Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Insurance

The 10th Circuit Court of Appeals unanimously ruled on Nov. 3 that Twin City Fire Insurance, a Hartford subsidiary, is not obligated to pay for TCT's defense in a 2015 lawsuit. TCT spent more than $4 million on attorneys and other costs over eight years of litigation.
Why it matters
The ruling leaves TCT responsible for its own legal expenses, with the court finding the policy did not require a defense because the suit was brought by a former TCT director within a year of that director's board service. For Wyoming businesses and policyholders, the decision illustrates how 'insured versus insured' exclusions can override expectations of coverage.
The 10th Circuit panel's ruling was unanimous, and TCT's litigation costs exceeded $4 million across eight years of proceedings. The extraction does not indicate whether TCT plans further appeals or what share of those costs, if any, may be recovered.
The players
Twin City Fire Insurance
The Hartford subsidiary that issued the policy under which TCT sought defense coverage, and which the courts found owed no duty to defend.
Hartford
The parent company of Twin City Fire Insurance, a long-established U.S. insurance and financial services firm.
Kelly Rankin
The U.S. District Court judge who ruled in February that the insurer was not obligated to defend TCT.
The details
The 2015 suit arose from TCT's conversion from a member-owned nonprofit cooperative to a private, for-profit company. A state district judge dismissed the lawsuit in 2022, the Wyoming Supreme Court affirmed in 2023, and TCT then sued its former insurer in federal court in 2024, where Judge Kelly Rankin ruled in February that the insurer had no duty to defend.
Timeline
2015: TCT converted from a nonprofit cooperative to a for-profit company, and the lawsuit was filed.
2022: A state district judge dismissed the lawsuit.
2023: The Wyoming Supreme Court affirmed the dismissal.
2024: TCT filed suit in federal court against Twin City Fire Insurance.
February 2026: Judge Kelly Rankin ruled the insurer was not obligated to defend TCT.
Market Dynamics
The decision applies the insured-versus-insured exclusion to a suit tied to a cooperative's conversion to for-profit status, a corporate restructuring that can generate internal disputes. It shows how policy exclusions drafted for director-related claims can shift defense costs onto the company itself.
Businesses converting from cooperative or nonprofit structures should review whether their directors-and-officers policies contain insured-versus-insured exclusions before a dispute arises. Policyholders facing defense costs should confirm early whether their coverage applies, since this case shows litigation expenses can accumulate for years.
The takeaway
Policies that exclude claims brought by insiders can leave a company paying its own defense for years, so reviewing those exclusions before a restructuring can prevent costly surprises. The ruling underscores that a suit's label as a class action does not guarantee coverage.
Further reading
For related coverage, see our Insurance section, which tracks policy disputes affecting Wyoming businesses and individuals.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Powell Tribune.






