Groups Urge Court to Keep School Funding Suit Alive

The West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals is weighing a motion by the attorney general and legislative leaders to dismiss a challenge to the state's public school funding formula.

Updated on Nov. 21, 2026 in Politics

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a simplified civic building facade with a pediment and a bell silhouette above rolling wooded ridgelines, in deep red and cream.
The West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals is weighing a motion by Attorney General John B. McCuskey and legislative leaders to dismiss a challenge to the state's school funding formula. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

The ACLU of West Virginia Foundation filed a brief Thursday urging the Supreme Court of Appeals to keep a constitutional challenge to the state's public school funding formula alive. Attorney General John B. McCuskey and legislative leaders have filed a motion to dismiss the case.

Why it matters

The ruling will decide whether the funding challenge is heard on its merits now or delayed, shaping how and when the state's school funding formula can be questioned in court. The outcome affects students and taxpayers across West Virginia, where school funding remains a central budget issue.

The five-justice court must decide procedural motions before reaching the merits of the funding challenge. Its choice among dismissal, abeyance, or full arguments has not been made, and the constitutional question remains unaddressed.

The players

John B. McCuskey

West Virginia's attorney general, who joined legislative leaders in moving to dismiss the school funding lawsuit.

American Civil Liberties Union of West Virginia Foundation

The state affiliate of the national civil liberties organization, which filed a brief urging the court to keep the funding challenge active.

The details

The case is an original-jurisdiction action before the state's highest court, and preliminary briefs have been submitted. The ACLU of West Virginia Foundation opposes dismissal, while McCuskey and legislative leaders argue the case should not proceed.

Timeline

  1. Thursday: ACLU of West Virginia Foundation filed its brief urging the court to keep the lawsuit alive.

  2. 2027 legislative session: The court could hold the litigation in abeyance until after this session.

Legal Context

The challenge asks the state's highest court to measure the public school funding formula against the state constitution's education guarantee. Whether the justices dismiss, defer or hear the case will shape how such funding disputes are litigated in West Virginia.

Residents and school districts will not see changes to the funding formula from this filing alone. Whether the court sets arguments or defers the case determines when a ruling on the formula could affect school budgets.

The takeaway

Procedural rulings often determine when constitutional questions about public funding are answered, not just whether they are. Readers tracking school budgets should watch whether the court acts on the motion or defers it past the 2027 session.

What happens next

The court may hold the litigation in abeyance until after the 2027 legislative session, which would postpone any merits arguments on the funding formula.

Further reading

For related court coverage, see the Law section on West Virginia state litigation.

Source note: This article includes information reported by WV News.