Milwaukee Judge Sentences Driver in Fatal Hit-and-Run

David Hall received a 13-year prison sentence following a crash that killed Carla Tyson in 2024.

Updated on Oct. 25, 2026 in Criminal Justice

Milwaukee Judge Sentences Driver in Fatal Hit-and-Run

Judge Laura Crivello sentenced 49-year-old David Hall to 13 years in prison for his role in a fatal hit-and-run crash. The incident resulted in the death of Carla Tyson, who was struck by Hall's truck before being hit by a police vehicle.

Why it matters

The case highlights the severe legal consequences of fleeing the scene of a fatal accident while already out on bond. It also triggered a wrongful-death lawsuit naming both the driver and the local police department.

David Hall received a 13-year sentence after being convicted of hit-and-run resulting in death and felony bail jumping. The defendant was also out on bond for a separate drug and gun case at the time of the fatal incident.

The players

David Hall

He is the 49-year-old defendant convicted of felony charges stemming from the fatal hit-and-run crash.

Carla Tyson

She was the victim of the fatal collision and had cerebral palsy.

Laura Crivello

She is the judge who presided over the criminal case and issued the 13-year sentence.

Milwaukee Police Department

The local agency is named as a defendant in an ongoing wrongful-death lawsuit regarding the incident.

The details

Surveillance footage captured Hall's truck hitting Carla Tyson, a woman with cerebral palsy, at West North Avenue and North 14th Street. Approximately 30 seconds later, Tyson was struck a second time by a passing Milwaukee police squad car.

July 27, 2024: The fatal crash occurred at West North Avenue and North 14th Street.
October 22, 2026: Jurors convicted David Hall of hit-and-run resulting in death and felony bail jumping.
November 18, 2026: A scheduling conference is set for the civil wrongful-death lawsuit.
December 2026: David Hall is scheduled for trial in his separate drug and gun case.

Legal Context

The sentence for David Hall follows a pattern where charges of felony bail jumping significantly increase the penalty for defendants who commit new crimes while released on bond. This case also highlights the ongoing civil scrutiny regarding police response protocols in Milwaukee.

The involvement of a police squad car in the incident has led to a civil wrongful-death lawsuit that could impact local department policies. Residents may see continued legal developments as the civil case moves toward its November 2026 scheduling conference.

The takeaway

This case underscores the severe cumulative sentencing risks for individuals charged with new felonies while on bond for previous offenses. Readers facing similar legal situations or those involved in civil litigation should consult with qualified legal counsel regarding their specific rights.

What happens next

A scheduling conference for the civil wrongful-death lawsuit is set for November 18, 2026, followed by a separate drug and gun trial in December 2026.