Umpires Ruled France Fly Ball Out in NLDS
A controversial ninth-inning call in Milwaukee kept the Padres' fly ball in play, securing an out.
Updated on Oct. 4, 2026 in Baseball
Live Poll
Do you believe home-stadium ground rules give host teams an unfair advantage in baseball?
Umpires ruled that a fly ball hit by Ty France during the ninth inning of the NLDS Game 1 was an out after it struck the stadium roof. The Milwaukee Brewers ultimately defeated the San Diego Padres in the opening game of the series.
Why it matters
The ruling played a critical role in the outcome of the opening game by denying a scoring opportunity for the Padres. Stadium ground rules dictate that balls hitting the roof structure over fair territory remain in play.
Official stadium ground rules classify a batted ball hitting the roof or its supporting structures over fair territory as an active ball. The play occurred in the ninth inning, preventing what would have been a 4-3 lead for the Padres.
The players
Ty France
He is a professional baseball player who hit the contested fly ball during the ninth inning.
Jackson Chourio
He is a professional baseball player who recorded the catch after the ball struck the roof.
Milwaukee Brewers
This is a Major League Baseball franchise that serves as the host organization for the NLDS games in Milwaukee.
San Diego Padres
This is a Major League Baseball franchise competing in the National League Division Series.
The details
During the ninth inning, Ty France hit a ball that struck the roof, which remained in play according to the local venue's guidelines. Brewers outfielder Jackson Chourio successfully caught the ball near the warning track, and the San Diego Padres' subsequent challenge to the call was denied.
Timeline
The umpires ruled the ball in play during Game 1 on Saturday night.
The Padres will look to even the series on Sunday.
Season Trajectory
This defensive play prevented a late-game rally, significantly altering the momentum of the opening series matchup. The result forces the Padres to adjust their strategy for the upcoming game to avoid a 2-0 deficit in the NLDS.
The ruling preserved the Milwaukee lead and officially recorded an out, shifting the statistical outcome of the ninth inning. Fantasy owners and bettors should note the final score impact as the series moves into Sunday's matchup.
The takeaway
Understanding venue-specific ground rules is essential for following postseason outcomes in non-traditional stadium environments. Fans should anticipate similar scrutiny regarding roof contact throughout the remainder of the series.
What happens next
The San Diego Padres and Milwaukee Brewers will face off in Game 2 of the NLDS on Sunday.
Further reading
For more analysis on this postseason matchup, visit the Baseball section.
Live Poll
Do you believe home-stadium ground rules give host teams an unfair advantage in baseball?
