Semolina Pasta Shop Forced to Close in Bay View

Owners of the Milwaukee pasta shop must vacate their Kinnickinnic Avenue location by early next year.

Updated on Oct. 2, 2026 in Openings & Closings

A weathered brick storefront facade in Milwaukee on an overcast day, signaling the closure of a local business. — Owners Petra and Andy Orlowski must vacate their Milwaukee pasta shop in Bay View by January 2027 following the building's sale. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you trust that local small businesses can maintain stability in your area?

After a property sale in May 2026, the owners of Semolina pasta shop were notified that they must vacate their retail space at 2474 S. Kinnickinnic Ave. by January 31, 2027. The business, which has operated in Bay View since 2021, received the notice on September 1, 2026.

Why it matters

The shop is closing because the new property owner plans to demolish the building along with a neighboring structure to make way for a new development project. The owners had requested an extension through January to remain operational during their busiest season of the year.

The shop has operated at 2474 S. Kinnickinnic Ave. since its founding in 2021. Current efforts to relocate the business focus on finding a new commercial kitchen space.

The players

Petra and Andy Orlowski

They are the husband-and-wife owners who founded the Semolina pasta shop.

The details

Owners Petra and Andy Orlowski received the notice to vacate via a text message after the property was sold to a developer. The couple is currently searching for a new location that can house their necessary commercial kitchen equipment.

Semolina opened at 2474 S. Kinnickinnic Ave. in 2021.
The property was sold in May 2026.
Owners received notice to vacate on September 1, 2026.
The business must vacate the property by January 31, 2027.

Market Landscape

This closure reflects the ongoing redevelopment of Milwaukee's Bay View neighborhood commercial corridor. The loss of established storefronts follows an established pattern of small retail shops being displaced by new construction projects.

Customers who frequent the Bay View pasta shop will see the business close its doors at the end of January. Regulars should monitor the owners for updates regarding a potential move to a new location.

The takeaway

When renting retail space, businesses without long-term lease protections can be vulnerable to sudden property sales and redevelopment plans. Owners often face significant logistical challenges when forced to relocate specialized facilities like commercial kitchens.