Prosecutors Drop Homicide Charge in Madison Shooting

A first-degree intentional homicide charge against a Madison man tied to an October 24 bar shooting has been dismissed without prejudice.

Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Violence

Flat-color editorial illustration of a stone civic courthouse facade with tall columns under a grey sky, evoking the institutional weight of a dismissed criminal case.
Dane County prosecutors dismissed a first-degree intentional homicide charge against a Madison man tied to an October 24 bar shooting on South Pinckney Street, without prejudice. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Dane County prosecutors have dismissed a first-degree intentional homicide charge against a Madison man arrested in connection with a deadly shooting outside a bar on South Pinckney Street. A motion to dismiss was filed by Dane County Assistant District Attorney Timothy Verhoff, and the dismissal took effect Friday, November 13.

Why it matters

Prosecutors said they can no longer sustain the charge because of additional information learned during the investigation, which leaves the question of who fired the fatal shot open for now. The dismissal without prejudice means the case could be refiled if new evidence emerges.

The first-degree intentional homicide charge was dismissed without prejudice on Friday, November 13, according to a motion filed by Assistant District Attorney Timothy Verhoff. The filing does not indicate whether any other charges remain pending or whether prosecutors plan to refile.

The players

Dane County District Attorney's Office

The Dane County District Attorney's Office prosecutes felony and misdemeanor cases in Wisconsin's second-most populous county, which includes the city of Madison.

The details

Police said the fatal shooting happened around 1:30 a.m. on October 24 outside a bar in the 100 block of South Pinckney Street. The man told police on October 26 that a fight had broken out and that everyone was told to leave, and he said he did not see the shooting and was not involved in the fight. He said he dropped a cousin off on Madison's east side and later let that cousin borrow his SUV.

Timeline

  1. October 24: Fatal shooting outside a South Pinckney Street bar around 1:30 a.m.

  2. October 26: The man gives a statement to police about the fight.

  3. November 13: Prosecutors dismiss the first-degree intentional homicide charge without prejudice.

  4. November 17: Court records showing the dismissal motion are reported.

Legal Context

Dismissals without prejudice allow Wisconsin prosecutors to drop a charge while keeping the option to refile, which preserves the case if new evidence emerges. This procedural step is common in homicide investigations where the identity of the shooter remains unsettled.

Madison residents who frequent South Pinckney Street bars may want to note that a fatal shooting remains unsolved and the charge has been dropped. Anyone with information about the October 24 incident is encouraged to contact law enforcement.

The takeaway

A dropped charge does not close a homicide case, and dismissals without prejudice leave room for refiling as investigators gather more information. Residents should watch for court filings if they want to follow the case.

Further reading

For more on local cases like this, browse Violence coverage from across the Madison area.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Wmtv15news.