Police Renew Appeal in 2006 Murder of Connie Boelter

Appleton police are seeking information 20 years after Connie Boelter, 56, was found murdered in her home, with a $10,000 reward offered.

Updated on Nov. 15, 2026 in Financial Crime

Police Renew Appeal in 2006 Murder of Connie Boelter

The Appleton Police Department renewed its public appeal for information on the November 15, 2006 murder of Connie Boelter, 56, who was found killed inside her East Northwood Drive home. Her killer has never been identified, and the homicide remains an active, open investigation.

Why it matters

Two decades after the killing, investigators say they have re-examined physical evidence and applied advances in forensic technology in hopes of identifying a suspect. The $10,000 reward is intended to prompt anyone with information to come forward.

The homicide remains an open investigation with no arrest made, and police are offering a $10,000 reward for information leading to an arrest and conviction. Investigators are asking the public to contact the Appleton Police Department at 920-832-5500 or APDTips@appletonwi.gov, or submit anonymous tips through the department website.

The players

Appleton Police Department

The municipal law enforcement agency serving Appleton, Wisconsin, which leads the open investigation into Boelter's death and manages the tip line and anonymous reporting system.

The details

Boelter, a mother and grandmother who worked as a loan processor at Wolf River Community Bank in Hortonville, was found murdered inside her residence on East Northwood Drive. Police say they have re-examined physical evidence over the past two decades and applied advancements in forensic technology to the case.

Timeline

  1. November 15, 2006: Connie Boelter is found murdered inside her Appleton home.

  2. November 15, 2026: Police renew their appeal on the 20th anniversary of her death.

Legal Context

Cold-case homicides like Boelter's are increasingly revisited as forensic methods improve, allowing previously collected evidence to yield new leads years or decades after the crime. Investigators in such cases often pair updated lab analysis with public appeals and rewards to generate tips that original inquiries could not obtain.

Residents with any information about the 2006 killing on East Northwood Drive are urged to contact the Appleton Police Department at 920-832-5500 or APDTips@appletonwi.gov, or submit an anonymous tip through the department website. The $10,000 reward remains available for information leading to an arrest and conviction.

The takeaway

Even cold cases two decades old can be reopened, and tips from the public remain central to solving them. Anyone with information, however small, can contact the Appleton Police Department confidentially.

Further reading

For more on local investigations, see Crime coverage across the Appleton area.