Audit Faults DPI Over School Report Card Changes
A 146-page Legislative Audit Bureau report reviews Wisconsin school report cards from 2022 through 2025 and makes 13 recommendations.
Updated on Nov. 22, 2026 in Politics

Live Poll
Do you trust your state's school report cards to accurately show how local schools perform?
The Legislative Audit Bureau issued a 146-page report on Friday reviewing Wisconsin school report cards for public, charter and private schools from 2022 through 2025. The audit was commissioned by the Joint Legislative Audit Committee in February 2025 after the Department of Public Instruction changed how report cards are scored.
Why it matters
The audit questions how the state scores and ranks schools, which affects how families and districts in Wisconsin judge school performance. Its 13 recommendations give the Department of Public Instruction a roadmap for changes to the scoring system.
The Legislative Audit Bureau's report covers school report cards from 2022 through 2025, with 95% of public school districts ranked three to five stars and 48% of students proficient in reading. The audit does not address how the department plans to implement its recommendations.
The players
Department of Public Instruction
Wisconsin's state education agency, which oversees public schools and produces the school report cards audited in the report.
Legislative Audit Bureau
The nonpartisan audit agency of the Wisconsin Legislature, which conducts performance and financial audits of state agencies.
Jill Underly
Wisconsin's State Superintendent of Public Instruction, who leads the Department of Public Instruction.
The details
The audit found the Department of Public Instruction did not broadly solicit feedback from educators or the public before changing testing cut scores, and could not document the feedback it did receive. The department weighs student achievement and growth more heavily than student performance when calculating overall scores in low-income districts.
Timeline
February 2025: Joint Legislative Audit Committee commissions the audit after the Department of Public Instruction changes report card scoring.
2024: The department rolls out new testing standards and updated cut scores.
October: Test scores are released showing 48% of students proficient in reading.
Friday: The Legislative Audit Bureau issues its 146-page report.
March 30, 2027: The department is due to report to the committee on implementing the recommendations.
Political Context
Gov. Tony Evers vetoed a 2021 bill that would have given all four priority areas equal weight, and the audit revives that dispute over how the state weighs student achievement and growth. Critics of the current formula argue it lets the department emphasize certain outcomes over others.
Families who use Wisconsin school report cards to compare schools should understand that the scoring formula is under review and may change. The audit's recommendations could alter how star ratings are assigned in the coming years.
The takeaway
The audit shows that how a state scores its schools is itself a policy choice, and changes to that choice can reshape how performance is judged. Readers should watch the department's response to the 13 recommendations, which is due in 2027.
What happens next
The Department of Public Instruction is due to report to the Joint Legislative Audit Committee by March 30, 2027, on its efforts to implement the audit's 13 recommendations.
Further reading
For related coverage, see Government reporting on how state agencies make policy decisions.
Source note: This article includes information reported by WisconsinWatch.
Live Poll
Do you trust your state's school report cards to accurately show how local schools perform?






