Judge Rules Wisconsin Absentee Voting Violates ADA
A Dane County judge rejected the Wisconsin Elections Commission's bid to reconsider a ruling that its absentee program denies disabled voters a private, independent vote.
Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Elections

Live Poll
Should Wisconsin let voters with print disabilities cast absentee ballots electronically?
Dane County Circuit Court Judge Everett Mitchell denied the Wisconsin Elections Commission's motion to reconsider his August ruling that the state's absentee voting program violates the Americans with Disabilities Act. The judge ordered the parties to mediate within 90 days and did not specify a remedy.
Why it matters
Mitchell found that the absentee program requires paper ballots, denying voters with print disabilities the ability to vote privately and independently. Wisconsin's approach to absentee ballots is now in legal dispute, and if mediation fails, the case will likely proceed to trial.
Judge Mitchell ordered mediation within 90 days of the Wednesday order and set no specific remedy. Wisconsin restricted electronic ballot delivery to military and overseas voters under a 2011 law, and the 2024 temporary injunction allowing emailed ballots for disabled voters was reversed in March 2025.
The players
Wisconsin Elections Commission
The state body responsible for administering Wisconsin's elections, which sought reconsideration of the ruling against its absentee voting program.
The details
Plaintiffs, including Disability Rights Wisconsin and the League of Women Voters of Wisconsin, filed the 2024 suit on behalf of four disabled voters seeking an accessible electronic method to request, receive and return absentee ballots. Possible remedies discussed include at-home devices or programs such as screen readers that convert text to speech or braille.
Timeline
2011: Wisconsin restricted electronic ballot delivery to military and overseas voters.
2024: Disability Rights Wisconsin and co-plaintiffs filed the lawsuit.
June 2024: Mitchell issued a temporary injunction allowing emailed ballots for disabled voters.
March 2025: The District II Court of Appeals reversed the temporary injunction.
August 2026: Mitchell ruled the absentee program violates the ADA.
Political Context
The ruling applies the Americans with Disabilities Act to Wisconsin's absentee voting rules, which were tightened by a 2011 law that limited electronic ballot delivery to military and overseas voters. The state's opposition to reconsideration reflects a broader defense of that restriction against the disability-rights plaintiffs' claims.
Wisconsin voters with print disabilities currently cannot cast an absentee ballot privately and independently under the state's current program. Any remedy adopted through mediation or trial could change how disabled voters request and return their ballots in future elections.
The takeaway
Accessibility rulings like this one show that voting rights for disabled residents depend on how ballots are delivered, not only on whether people are allowed to vote. Readers following Wisconsin elections should watch the 90-day mediation window for any concrete remedy.
What happens next
Mediation between the parties must occur within 90 days of Mitchell's Wednesday order, after which the matter will likely head to trial if no solution is reached.
Further reading
Explore more Wisconsin Elections coverage for context on how the state runs its ballot systems.
Live Poll
Should Wisconsin let voters with print disabilities cast absentee ballots electronically?






