Appeals Court Limits Lowered Drunk-Driving Threshold
Wisconsin's Court of Appeals upheld dismissal of a third-offense 0.02 blood alcohol charge based on a prior refusal-related license revocation.
Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Substance Abuse

The Wisconsin Court of Appeals affirmed a circuit court's dismissal of a third-offense 0.02 PAC drunk-driving charge against a Wisconsin man. The court held that a prior revocation tied to refusing a warrantless blood draw cannot be used to lower the threshold from 0.08.
Why it matters
The ruling reinforces that drivers cannot be penalized more harshly for exercising their right to refuse a warrantless blood draw. It affects how prosecutors across Wisconsin may apply enhanced impaired-driving thresholds to repeat offenders.
The State sought to apply a 0.02 blood alcohol threshold, a fourth of the standard 0.08 limit, based on a prior refusal-related revocation. The stub does not indicate whether the State will pursue further review of the ruling.
The players
Wisconsin Court of Appeals
The Wisconsin Court of Appeals is the state's intermediate appellate court, which reviews decisions from circuit courts across Wisconsin.
The details
A 2024 traffic stop led to a search-warrant blood test showing blood alcohol concentration above the applicable limit. Prosecutors charged the man under the lower 0.02 threshold because of a 2012 license revocation stemming from a 2011 refusal to submit to a warrantless blood draw, but a circuit court dismissed that charge.
Timeline
2011: The man refused a warrantless blood draw.
2012: His license was revoked following the refusal.
2024: A traffic stop led to the search-warrant blood test.
November 16, 2026: The Court of Appeals decision was published.
Legal Precedent
The decision applies State v. Forrett, which held that penalties cannot be imposed for refusing a warrantless blood draw, to bar using a refusal-based revocation to lower the PAC threshold. It also distinguishes State v. Sparby-Duncan because the man had no ignition interlock device order.
Drivers in Wisconsin who refuse a warrantless blood test cannot have that refusal used to impose a stricter drunk-driving threshold on them later. Repeat-offense charges in the state will be evaluated under this appellate limit.
The takeaway
Refusing a warrantless blood draw does not expose Wisconsin drivers to a lower legal limit on later charges. Anyone facing an impaired-driving case should review how prior revocations are counted.
Further reading
Explore more on Substance Abuse rulings and related impaired-driving policy in Wisconsin.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Wisconsin Law Journal - WI Legal News & Resources.










