Everett Man Gets 50 Years to Life for 1980s Murders
A cold-case detective's staged DNA sample collection led to the conviction in two decades-old killings.
Updated on Nov. 21, 2026 in Criminal Justice

An Everett man was sentenced on May 13, 2026, to at least 50 years and up to life in prison after admitting to the 1980s killings of Judy Weaver and Susan Vesey. Investigators tied him to the Weaver case through a DNA profile matched in CODIS in November 2023.
Why it matters
The case shows how decades-old DNA profiles can be linked to suspects years after a crime, reopening unsolved homicides in the Everett area. It also highlights investigative methods used to obtain a fresh DNA sample needed to confirm a database match.
The Everett man pleaded guilty to two counts of first-degree murder and received a sentence of at least 50 years, with a maximum of life in prison. The case is now closed, with no further proceedings reported in the source.
The players
Everett Police Department
The Everett Police Department is the municipal law enforcement agency that investigated both killings and made the arrest in the case.
Susan Logothetti
Susan Logothetti is an Everett police detective who joined the department in 2012, became a sex-crimes detective in 2019, and took on cold-case homicides in 2022.
The details
Judy Weaver was found dead in her Everett home on June 2, 1984, and Susan Vesey was found murdered by her husband on July 12, 1980. A DNA profile from the Weaver case matched the suspect through CODIS in November 2023, and detective Susan Logothetti posed as a market researcher to collect a new DNA sample from him at a survey, using used gum he discarded. Police arrested him in May 2024.
Timeline
June 2, 1984: Judy Weaver's body was discovered in her Everett home.
July 12, 1980: Susan Vesey was found murdered by her husband.
November 2023: A DNA profile matched the suspect through CODIS.
May 2024: Police arrested the suspect for the Weaver murder.
May 13, 2026: The suspect was sentenced to at least 50 years in prison.
Legal Context
The case reflects a broader pattern in which DNA databases such as CODIS are used to revisit decades-old homicides, often leading to arrests long after the original crimes. Prosecutions built on cold-case matches typically require a confirming sample from the suspect, as occurred in this case.
Residents with unresolved cases from the 1980s may see renewed investigative attention as cold-case units apply DNA database matching to older evidence. The case confirms that verified DNA leads can result in convictions decades later, which may matter to families of victims in unsolved homicides.
The takeaway
Cold-case convictions often depend on patient, methodical work that combines database matches with fresh evidence, so older unsolved crimes remain open to resolution. Families and communities should be aware that DNA records from decades ago can still produce accountability.
Further reading
For more on how courts handle long-delayed prosecutions, browse Criminal Justice coverage from Everett.
Source note: This article includes information reported by GreekReporter.






