Nathan McMahon Named Vermont Playoff MVP

The Essex junior outside back collected 58.4% of votes in the All-USA Vermont high school boys soccer balloting.

Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Soccer

Nathan McMahon Named Vermont Playoff MVP

Essex junior outside back Nathan McMahon was named the All-USA Vermont high school boys soccer MVP of the 2026 playoffs, receiving 58.4% of the 1,573 votes cast. McMahon beat out 10 other standout performers from championship-winning teams across four divisions.

Why it matters

The award recognizes a single player's impact on a playoff run that ended Burr and Burton's 32-game unbeaten streak and carried Essex to the Division I title. It gives Vermont high school soccer fans a clear reference point for the state's top postseason performer this fall.

The MVP result came from an online reader ballot open November 9 through November 15, 2026, with McMahon taking 58.4% of 1,573 votes. The vote split for the remaining candidates was not reported.

The players

Nathan McMahon

A junior outside back for Essex who was named the All-USA Vermont high school boys soccer MVP for the 2026 playoffs.

Burlington Free Press

The Vermont daily newspaper that ran the online MVP voting at burlingtonfreepress.com.

The details

McMahon struck a 2OT walkoff winner from nearly 50 yards out in Essex's Division I semifinal win over reigning champion Burr and Burton. Essex went on to win the Division I championship.

Timeline

  1. Fall 2026: Postseason play for championship-winning teams took place.

  2. Monday, Nov. 9, 2026: Online MVP voting began.

  3. Sunday, Nov. 15, 2026, 9 p.m.: Online MVP voting closed.

  4. Nov. 16, 2026: Results were announced.

Season Trajectory

Essex's Division I semifinal win ended Burr and Burton's 32-game unbeaten run, the reigning champion's streak, and the Hornets went on to claim the title. McMahon's MVP honor caps a postseason in which a single breakthrough result reshaped Vermont's Division I hierarchy.

The MVP honor is a state-level recognition rather than a team or league roster decision, so it does not alter standings or playoff seeding. Fans tracking Vermont high school soccer can use the award as a reference for the state's top postseason performers in the 2026 season.

The takeaway

A single player's late-game strike in a semifinal can define an entire postseason, and McMahon's MVP honor recognizes that kind of decisive contribution. Readers following Vermont high school soccer can track how the state's top performers emerge in the next season.

Further reading

For more on the season's top results, browse the latest Soccer coverage across Vermont high schools.

Source note: This article includes information reported by The Burlington Free Press.