Judge Denies Motion to Dismiss River's Edge Lawsuit
A Richmond judge allows a $40 million lawsuit over construction defects at the River's Edge apartment building to proceed.
Updated on Oct. 21, 2026 in Construction
Live Poll
Should developers be held liable for undisclosed construction defects discovered years after a building is sold?
A Richmond Circuit Court judge denied a motion to dismiss a lawsuit filed by Four Mile Capital regarding alleged construction defects at the River's Edge apartment complex. The plaintiff, which purchased the property for $47.5 million in 2021, is seeking over $40 million in damages following reports of persistent water leaks.
Why it matters
The lawsuit alleges that the 10-story building was not constructed according to design specifications and that the plaintiff was misled about the extent of structural issues at the time of purchase. Future remediation plans include re-cladding the building facade, which will require the relocation of current tenants.
The River's Edge building includes 212 units across 10 stories with a 92% occupancy rate. Monthly rents currently start at $1,400 for one-bedroom units and $2,000 for two-bedroom units.
The players
Four Mile Capital
This is the real estate investment firm that purchased the River's Edge apartment building.
Jacqueline McClenney
She is the Richmond Circuit Court judge overseeing the ongoing civil litigation.
Purcell Construction Corp
This firm was involved in the original construction of the apartment property.
The details
The legal action includes claims of fraud, business conspiracy, breach of contract, and negligence related to the state of the property. While the judge sustained demurrers on some counts against Purcell Construction Corp, the broader case against other defendants continues toward a requested jury trial.
Timeline
2021: Four Mile Capital purchased the River's Edge apartments.
2025: Four Mile Capital filed the initial lawsuit.
September 21, 2026: Judge Jacqueline McClenney issued the opinion and order.
October 13, 2026: Four Mile Capital filed an amended complaint.
Market Landscape
This litigation highlights the risks associated with commercial real estate investments and the legal mechanisms used to address latent construction defects after a sale. It underscores the competitive pressure on property owners to maintain asset value amid significant structural remediation demands.
Residents of the 212-unit complex face potential disruption as plans for re-cladding the building facade involve temporary tenant relocation. Affected tenants should monitor official communications for updates regarding the schedule and logistics of the upcoming construction work.
The takeaway
Property investors should conduct rigorous due diligence regarding historical construction quality to mitigate the risk of multi-million dollar structural liabilities. Tenants in buildings facing major litigation or remediation should ensure they understand their rights regarding lease continuity and relocation assistance.
Further reading
For more information on ongoing infrastructure and development news, visit the Richmond Construction section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Richmond BizSense.
Live Poll
Should developers be held liable for undisclosed construction defects discovered years after a building is sold?
