Virginia Supreme Court Denies McLean Church Rehearing

The state's highest court declined to reconsider a ruling that sends a dispute over a 2021 church elder vote back to Fairfax County Circuit Court.

Updated on Nov. 10, 2026 in Christianity

Photograph of a white-steepled church spire above bare oak branches beside a red-brick courthouse wing across an empty lawn under overcast sky.
The Virginia Supreme Court on Wednesday declined to rehear McLean Bible Church's appeal, sending a dispute over its 2021 elder election back to Fairfax County Circuit Court. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

The Virginia Supreme Court issued a one-sentence order denying McLean Bible Church's petition for rehearing in a lawsuit over the church's July 2021 elder election. The order affirms a May Court of Appeals ruling that returned the case to the Fairfax County Circuit Court.

Why it matters

The case will proceed in circuit court to determine whether the plaintiffs can prevail, keeping a long-running internal dispute over church governance in the courts. The outcome could shape how Northern Virginia congregations interpret their own constitutions and voting provisions.

The complaint alleges that members were denied secret ballots and were designated 'inactive' to disqualify them from voting, with eight consecutive missed Sundays used as the threshold. The Fairfax County Circuit Court has dismissed the complaint twice, and the case has not reached a determination on the merits.

The players

McLean Bible Church

McLean Bible Church is a large evangelical congregation in Northern Virginia that is the defendant in this lawsuit over its 2021 elder election.

Virginia Supreme Court

The Virginia Supreme Court is the highest appellate court in the state, and it denied the church's petition for rehearing in this case.

Fairfax County Circuit Court

The Fairfax County Circuit Court is the trial-level court that has twice dismissed the complaint and will hear the case on remand.

The details

Five longtime members filed a complaint over the July 2021 election, alleging that leaders sought to remove theological conservatives from positions of power. Plaintiffs' attorney argues the dispute is a contract dispute over the church constitution's voting provisions rather than a religious decision. The Virginia Supreme Court earlier rejected an appeal due to a procedural error in the church's filing.

Timeline

  1. July 2021: MBC held an elder election that members allege involved ballot violations.

  2. 2022: The Fairfax County Circuit Court dismissed the members' first complaint.

  3. June 2023: The Court of Appeals of Virginia reversed the dismissal.

  4. December 2024: The Fairfax County Circuit Court dismissed the lawsuit a second time.

  5. May 2026: The Court of Appeals ruling sent the case back to circuit court.

Season Trajectory

The case follows the 2023 Court of Appeals reversal, which had already revived the members' claims after the circuit court's first dismissal. Its return to circuit court keeps the dispute over church governance unresolved while the plaintiffs prepare jurisdictional discovery requests.

Members and attendees of McLean Bible Church may face continued uncertainty about church governance and voting rights while the case proceeds in circuit court. Residents of McLean and Northern Virginia may follow the case as it could influence how local congregations handle elder elections and membership status.

The takeaway

Church governance disputes can end up in civil court when a congregation's own constitution governs voting and membership. Members with questions about their rights should review their church's written bylaws and seek legal advice.

Further reading

For more on faith communities in the region, explore Christianity coverage from McLean.

Source note: This article includes information reported by The Christian Post.