Judge Denies New Trial in Lynchburg Murder Case
A Lynchburg judge rejected motions to overturn a second-degree murder conviction in the 2021 death of Clarissa Jones.
Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Crime

Judge F. Patrick Yeatts denied motions to set aside the second-degree murder conviction of a Lynchburg man, along with a request for a new trial and an evidentiary hearing. The man's sentencing hearing is scheduled for Monday.
Why it matters
The ruling leaves in place a jury verdict that followed a mistrial and a second trial, closing off the defense's effort to revisit witness testimony before sentencing. It affects the Lynchburg Circuit Court's handling of a case in which the victim, 37-year-old Clarissa Jones, died in November 2021.
The man was found guilty of second-degree murder, concealing evidence of a felony, transporting or concealing a dead body, and felony obstruction of justice, and he is awaiting sentencing. Judge Yeatts rejected the defense's motions on Wednesday, and the sentencing hearing is set for Monday, November 23, at 1:30 p.m.
The players
Lynchburg Circuit Court
The Lynchburg Circuit Court is the trial-level court in Lynchburg, Virginia, that heard the case and issued the rulings on the defense motions.
Michael Pflieger
Michael Pflieger is the prosecutor who represented the Commonwealth in the case and stated that no promises or plea deal were made with the jail inmate.
The details
The victim, Clarissa Jones, died in November 2021, and prosecutors allege the man traveled to Lynchburg and strangled her. The defense argued that the testimony of a witness, Kenya Johnson, changed between the preliminary hearing and trial, but the judge said such differences do not by themselves require a new hearing or retrial. Prosecutor Michael Pflieger said no promises or plea deal were made with the jail inmate who was called to testify.
Timeline
November 2021: Clarissa Jones died, and prosecutors allege the murder occurred.
March 2022: Kenya Johnson testified at the preliminary hearing.
September 2025: The first trial began and ended in a mistrial on the second day.
March 6, 2026: The jury returned guilty verdicts on all four charges.
Monday, November 23, 2026, 1:30 p.m.: Sentencing hearing scheduled.
Legal Context
The judge's reasoning applies the standard that differences between preliminary hearing and trial testimony do not alone justify an evidentiary hearing or new trial in Virginia circuit courts. The decision shows how a second trial, after a mistrial over access to cellphone location data, can proceed to a verdict that survives post-trial challenges.
The ruling means the verdict stands and sentencing will proceed on Monday, so the case moves toward a final outcome without a new trial. Residents of Lynchburg who followed the 2021 death of Clarissa Jones will see the case reach its sentencing phase in the local circuit court.
The takeaway
Post-trial challenges based on differences between testimony at a preliminary hearing and at trial do not by themselves win a new trial. Readers following Lynchburg court cases can track sentencing dates through the Lynchburg Circuit Court docket.
What happens next
Sentencing is scheduled for Monday, November 23, 2026, at 1:30 p.m. in Lynchburg Circuit Court.
Further reading
For more on how local courts handle cases like this, see Criminal Justice coverage in Lynchburg.
Source note: This article includes information reported by NewsAdvance.






