Shoemakers American Grille Will Close in Lynchburg

The restaurant will serve its final dinner on October 3, 2026, ahead of a planned hotel expansion.

Updated on Sept. 21, 2026 in Openings & Closings

Isometric editorial illustration of a brick building facade transitioning from commercial space to hotel rooms, representing urban renovation. — Shoemakers American Grille will close its Lynchburg location on October 3, 2026, as the Craddock Terry Hotel repurposes the space for 22 new guest rooms. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you support replacing long-standing local businesses with expanded hotel or tourism facilities in your area?

Shoemakers American Grille will close its downtown Lynchburg doors on October 3, 2026, after 18 years of operations. The space will be converted into 22 new guest rooms for the Craddock Terry Hotel.

Why it matters

The closure is part of a larger renovation project at the Craddock Terry Hotel to expand its lodging capacity. Management is repurposing the existing restaurant and event center space to accommodate increased demand for hotel rooms in the city.

Shoemakers American Grille concludes an 18-year tenure in the city, while the Craddock Terry Hotel prepares to add 22 new guest rooms to its existing inventory.

The players

Shoemakers American Grille

This establishment operated in downtown Lynchburg for 18 years before announcing its closure.

Craddock Terry Hotel

This hotel serves as the host site for the restaurant and event center currently undergoing renovations.

Waterstone Pizza

This dining establishment will remain operational while the surrounding hotel properties undergo renovations.

The details

The restaurant and its associated event center are closing to allow for a major renovation of the Craddock Terry Hotel site. While the restaurant ceases operations, Waterstone Pizza will remain open and continue to accept existing restaurant gift cards.

October 3, 2026: The restaurant serves its final dinner and ceases accepting gift cards.
October 31, 2026: The hotel event center closes its operations.

Market Landscape

The closure follows the local trend of adaptive reuse of industrial buildings in downtown Lynchburg by repurposing commercial dining space into modern lodging. This shift reflects a broader strategy among historic property owners to prioritize room capacity over on-site event services.

Patrons holding gift cards for the restaurant must use them by October 3, 2026, though they will remain valid at Waterstone Pizza thereafter. Guests planning to visit the Craddock Terry Hotel can expect ongoing renovations as the property expands its guest capacity.

The takeaway

Customers should prioritize spending their remaining restaurant balances before the October deadline to avoid loss of value. The transition highlights the ongoing evolution of historic hospitality properties as they adapt to current market demands for more guest accommodations.