Former Sheriff Bushey Found Guilty of Assault
A judge convicted former Middlesex County Sheriff David P. Bushey of misdemeanor assault and battery in a non-jury trial in Essex County.
Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in Criminal Justice

Former Middlesex County Sheriff David P. Bushey was found guilty of misdemeanor assault and battery in Essex County General District Court on November 19. Judge Julia Hutt Sichol sentenced him to 30 days in jail, fully suspended for 12 months, with conditions including no contact with the complainant and good behavior.
Why it matters
The case involved an alleged offense against a former female employee of the Middlesex County Sheriff's Office, and the court found the complainant credible. The outcome places a former elected law enforcement official's conduct under judicial review within Virginia's court system.
The conviction stands as a misdemeanor finding in Essex County General District Court, with Judge Julia Hutt Sichol suspending the entire 30-day jail term for 12 months. Bushey may still appeal to Essex County Circuit Court, and the extraction does not say whether he intends to.
The players
David P. Bushey
Bushey is a former Middlesex County Sheriff who served 14 years in the office before resigning in March 2026, and he now resides in Wisconsin.
Julia Hutt Sichol
Sichol is the judge of the Essex County General District Court who presided over the non-jury bench trial and imposed the suspended sentence.
The details
Bushey's attorney asked the judge to take the case under advisement and defer a finding, while the Essex Commonwealth's Attorney did not seek jail time. The judge found the complainant, Erin Elizabeth Duke of Hartfield, credible and imposed suspension conditions including no contact with Duke.
Timeline
March 2026: Bushey resigned as sheriff after 14 years, citing health reasons.
November 19, 2026: Bushey was found guilty of misdemeanor assault and battery.
November 25, 2026: Further details are scheduled to appear in the Sentinel.
Legal Context
The case follows a pattern of Virginia sheriffs facing accountability proceedings for conduct toward their own staff, and it arrives in a Commonwealth where sentencing decisions often turn on suspension and deferral. Because the conviction was entered without a jury, the outcome rests on the judge's credibility assessment of the complainant.
Residents of Middlesex County and Essex County may see changes in leadership and oversight at the sheriff's office following Bushey's resignation and conviction. The suspended sentence means no jail time is currently being served, but the no-contact condition remains in force while the suspension period runs.
The takeaway
Court records show that suspended sentences can resolve misdemeanor convictions without incarceration, but conditions such as no-contact orders remain enforceable for the full suspension period. Readers following similar cases can track appeal deadlines in the originating district court.
Further reading
Explore more on Criminal Justice coverage across Virginia courts and sheriff's offices.
Source note: This article includes information reported by SSentinel.






