Martinez Bill Would End Virginia's Dillon Rule

Delegate Marty Martinez is introducing legislation in the General Assembly to expand local government authority by ending the Dillon Rule.

Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in City Hall

Martinez Bill Would End Virginia's Dillon Rule

Live Poll

Should Virginia cities and counties have more power to make their own local decisions?

Delegate Marty Martinez, a Democrat from Loudoun, is introducing legislation in the General Assembly to upend the Dillon Rule, which limits Virginia local governments to powers explicitly granted by the state. The bill would give local governments more authority, though the coalition behind it does not seek power to create new crimes or expand police powers.

Why it matters

The Dillon Rule has constrained Virginia localities since the 1800s, as shown by the 1890s ruling that Winchester could not offer a $500 reward for helping convict an arsonist. Bruce McDonald of Old Dominion University says the rule hamstrings local governments, making the bill's outcome relevant to how Virginia communities can respond to local needs.

The Dillon Rule traces to the 1800s and limits local authority to powers explicitly granted by the General Assembly. The article does not specify the bill's text, its vote prospects, or its timeline for consideration.

The players

Marty Martinez

Democratic delegate representing Loudoun in the Virginia General Assembly, who is introducing the bill to end the Dillon Rule.

Bruce McDonald

Professor at Old Dominion University who has commented that the Dillon Rule hamstrings local governments in Virginia.

The details

Virginia local governments currently operate under the Dillon Rule, a tradition dating to the 1800s that restricts their authority. Delegate Marty Martinez is pushing legislation to upend the rule, while the coalition supporting the bill says it does not want to give localities power to create new crimes or expand police authority.

Timeline

  1. 1800s: Virginia's tradition of limited local government authority begins.

  2. 1890s: The Supreme Court of Appeals rules that Winchester lacked authority to offer a $500 reward.

Political Context

The bill's supporters seek to overturn the Dillon Rule as applied in the 1890s Winchester case, in which the Supreme Court of Appeals drew on Iowa jurist John Dillon's opinion. Opponents of the rule argue it limits local responses, while the coalition behind the bill has specifically disavowed any push for local power to create crimes or expand policing.

If passed, the bill would let Virginia localities act on matters now reserved to the state, affecting local budgets and programs. Residents would see changes in what their city and county governments can authorize without first obtaining General Assembly approval.

The takeaway

Whether Virginia localities gain broader authority depends on the General Assembly's handling of Martinez's bill. Residents interested in local powers can track how their representatives vote on the measure.

Further reading

For related local government coverage, see City Hall on Wisevoter.

Live Poll

Should Virginia cities and counties have more power to make their own local decisions?