Judge Orders DNA Testing in Carter Retrial

Douglas Carter, 71, was freed from death row after a 1985 aggravated murder conviction was overturned, and the prosecution has withdrawn its death penalty notice.

Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Criminal Justice

Judge Orders DNA Testing in Carter Retrial

Provo Judge Derek Pullan ordered DNA testing of evidence in the retrial of Douglas Stewart Carter, 71, whose conviction for the aggravated murder of Eva Olesen was overturned after nearly 40 years on death row. The prosecution withdrew its notice of intent to seek the death penalty.

Why it matters

The case turns on whether forensic testing can resolve questions raised by recanted witness testimony and an earlier retesting that excluded Carter as a possible contributor. The outcome could shape how Utah courts handle long-running capital cases with contested evidence.

Carter is out of jail awaiting retrial, and the prosecution has withdrawn the death penalty. Briefings in the case are expected to be completed on Dec. 11, and the judge ordered that no consumptive testing may be performed without a separate court order.

The players

Derek Pullan

Utah judge presiding over Douglas Carter's retrial, who ordered the DNA testing and is set to retire after Dec. 11.

Utah Supreme Court

The state's highest court, which ruled in 2025 on constitutional violations in Carter's original trial.

The details

Several witnesses have recanted their testimony, claiming the Provo City Police Department interfered with their statements. The state will test evidence first, after which the defense will conduct independent testing; the judge also temporarily removed a media outlet's permission to carry proceedings after it broadcast attorneys' conversation before court.

Timeline

  1. February 1985: Eva Olesen was found dead inside her home.

  2. June 1985: Douglas Carter was arrested and charged with Olesen's murder.

  3. June 30, 1995: Carter's scheduled execution date, later delayed repeatedly.

  4. 2025: The Utah Supreme Court ruled on constitutional violations in Carter's trial.

  5. Dec. 11: Briefings expected to be completed, Judge Pullan's last day before retirement.

Legal Context

The retrial follows the Utah Supreme Court's 2025 ruling on constitutional violations in Carter's original trial, which vacated his death sentence and cleared the way for a new proceeding. The case illustrates how decades-old capital convictions can be reopened when forensic retesting and recanted testimony challenge the original evidence.

The case shows how a conviction can be reopened decades later, which affects anyone following how Utah courts handle capital cases and forensic evidence. Residents interested in the proceedings can track the court's schedule as briefings are completed in December.

The takeaway

Long-running convictions can be revisited when new forensic testing and recanted testimony emerge, and the results of pending DNA analysis will determine whether the retrial moves forward on the evidence presented.

What happens next

Briefings in the case are expected to be completed on Dec. 11, when Judge Pullan's time on the bench ends with his retirement.

Further reading

Explore more Provo criminal justice coverage for context on local court proceedings.

Source note: This article includes information reported by ABC 4.