Male-Heavy Deer Herds Linked to Female Decline
BYU researchers report that higher male-to-female mule deer ratios are associated with poorer female body condition and slower population growth.
Updated on Nov. 10, 2026 in Hunting

Live Poll
Should hunting limits focus on protecting female deer rather than harvesting males?
A study published in Ecological Solutions and Evidence found that increasing the proportion of male mule deer is associated with lower nutritional condition among females and reduced population growth. The research used 15 years of productivity data and seven years of body reserve dynamics data.
Why it matters
Mule deer populations across western North America have continued to decline, and the findings suggest that harvest management decisions affecting the male-to-female ratio may influence herd health. Utah wildlife managers may need to consider these dynamics when setting hunting limits.
The study drew on 15 years of mule deer productivity data and seven years of body reserve data, with females captured annually by helicopter net-gunning. Male mule deer are about 50% larger than females and consume more forage.
The players
Ranjana Pal
Ranjana Pal is a researcher and co-author of the study examining how male-to-female ratios affect mule deer health.
Randy Larsen
Randy Larsen is a co-author of the study and a researcher involved in mule deer population analysis.
Brock McMillan
Brock McMillan is a co-author of the study and a researcher involved in the Brigham Young University wildlife research.
Utah Division of Wildlife Resources
The Utah Division of Wildlife Resources manages the state's wildlife, including big game hunting regulations and population monitoring.
The details
Researchers captured female mule deer at the start of each winter, recording body mass, size, and rump fat before release. Measurements showed decreasing body fat accumulation in females in areas managed for high male-to-female ratios, which the authors suggest may reflect increased competition for summer and fall forage.
Timeline
2023 winter: Some Utah areas recorded 50% adult female mortality.
1980s-1990s: Interest in deer hunting surged, shifting management strategies.
November 10, 2026: The study findings were published.
Roadmap
Mule deer numbers across western North America have continued to fall for years, prompting managers to examine harvest practices more closely. This study adds a specific mechanism, linking male-heavy sex ratios to weaker female condition and slower herd growth.
Hunters in Utah may see management decisions shaped by these findings as state wildlife agencies consider harvest limits that affect male-to-female ratios. The research points to practical tradeoffs between buck harvest levels and the long-term health of female deer herds.
The takeaway
Balancing male and female deer numbers may matter as much as total population size for herd health. Hunters and managers alike can consider sex ratios when evaluating long-term mule deer sustainability.
Further reading
Explore more on Hunting for related coverage of wildlife management in Utah.
Live Poll
Should hunting limits focus on protecting female deer rather than harvesting males?










