Appeals Court Upholds Jail Term for Rock-Throwing Case

A San Antonio man's criminal mischief conviction and two-year state jail sentence for damaging a neighbor's home are affirmed on appeal.

Updated on Nov. 22, 2026 in Crime

Appeals Court Upholds Jail Term for Rock-Throwing Case

The Fourth Court of Appeals in San Antonio affirmed the criminal mischief conviction of a San Antonio man, a private individual, and upheld his two-year state jail sentence. The man was found to have thrown rocks at a neighbor's home, breaking windows and damaging door frames and an interior wall.

Why it matters

The ruling confirms that the reasonable cost of repairs can establish the financial loss required for a criminal mischief conviction, and the court rejected all three challenges raised on appeal. For San Antonio residents, it shows how property damage cases are measured and sentenced in the local courts.

The Fourth Court of Appeals affirmed the criminal mischief conviction and two-year state jail sentence on November 18, 2026. The contractor's $4,400 estimate, which covered four replacement windows along with labor, materials and painting, placed the damage within the charged dollar range, and the ruling does not address any further appeal.

The players

Fourth Court of Appeals

The Texas intermediate appellate court based in San Antonio that reviews criminal and civil rulings from trial courts across its district.

The details

On September 8, 2022, the defendant allegedly told a neighbor to stay out of his business, then threw rocks at the neighbor's house, breaking a window. The neighbor's wife called 911 during the incident, and the neighbor later found several broken windows, damaged frames and a hole in an interior wall.

Timeline

  1. September 8, 2022: The defendant threw rocks at the neighbor's home.

  2. November 18, 2026: The Fourth Court of Appeals affirmed the conviction and sentence.

Legal Context

The decision applies the Texas Penal Code's criminal mischief statute, which grades the offense by the dollar value of property damage, and it confirms that a reasonable repair estimate can satisfy that threshold. Similar property damage prosecutions in Texas courts are typically decided by the value of repairs rather than the intent behind the act.

Property owners in San Antonio who suffer damage from a neighbor's conduct can rely on documented repair estimates to support a criminal mischief charge, as this ruling shows. The decision also illustrates that such cases can result in state jail time rather than only civil remedies.

The takeaway

Documenting property damage with an itemized professional estimate can be decisive in criminal mischief cases, since courts measure financial loss by reasonable repair costs. Homeowners facing similar damage should keep receipts and contractor bids.

Further reading

For more on how local courts handle property cases, see Criminal Justice coverage from San Antonio.

Source note: This article includes information reported by The Times of India.