Appeals Court Dismisses Teacher Union Suit Against HISD

A state appeals court sided with Houston ISD, letting its performance-pay plan for teacher raises stand for now.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Administration

Isometric editorial illustration of two unequal stacks of plain coins beside a solid oxblood wedge on a cream surface, evoking how school pay funds are allocated.
Houston ISD may keep distributing state teacher retention funds through its performance-pay plan after a state appeals court dismissed the Houston Federation of Teachers' lawsuit. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should local school districts pay teachers based on performance rather than years of experience?

The First Court of Appeals vacated a temporary injunction and dismissed the Houston Federation of Teachers' lawsuit against Houston Independent School District on Tuesday. The court found the union did not first exhaust its administrative remedies with the Texas Education Agency, so the district may continue spending Teacher Retention Allotment funds under its performance-pay plan for now.

Why it matters

The ruling clears HISD to distribute state retention money through a pay-for-performance approach rather than strictly tenure-based raises, affecting how teacher pay is allocated across the Houston district. The decision also turns on procedure, leaving the underlying dispute over eligibility for the enhanced program unresolved.

The Teacher Retention Allotment, created under House Bill 2 for the 2025-26 school year, directs districts above 5,000 students to give guaranteed raises of $2,500 for three to four years of experience and $5,000 for five or more years. The court dismissed on jurisdictional grounds, so the merits of the eligibility dispute remain unresolved.

The players

Houston Independent School District

HISD is the largest school district in Texas and the public school system serving the city of Houston.

Mike Miles

Mike Miles is the superintendent of Houston Independent School District, known for pushing performance-based pay and reforms in the district.

The details

The Houston Federation of Teachers sued HISD, arguing the district had to distribute the money based on a tenure model and that it was ineligible for the enhanced program. The appeals court held the union had to go through the Texas Education Agency first and that a district may use performance pay while its application is pending, regardless of final state approval. A lower court had blocked HISD from using state funds for anything other than their stated purpose; that injunction is now vacated.

Timeline

  1. 2025-26 school year: Texas Legislature's House Bill 2 creates the Teacher Retention Allotment.

  2. Tuesday, November 17, 2026: First Court of Appeals vacates the injunction and dismisses the lawsuit.

  3. Tuesday night, November 17, 2026: HISD Superintendent Mike Miles announces the win at a DAC meeting.

Legal Context

The ruling tests how far districts may go in using performance pay under the Teacher Retention Allotment created by House Bill 2, which required guaranteed experience-based raises for larger districts. The court's procedural holding signals that such disputes may be resolved first through the Texas Education Agency rather than in court.

Houston-area teachers should check how their 2025-26 raises were calculated, since the ruling lets HISD keep using performance pay for now. The union may still pursue the eligibility question through the Texas Education Agency before the dispute is settled.

The takeaway

Teacher pay disputes in Texas may first have to pass through state education administrators before they reach a courtroom. Educators in Houston should watch how HISD applies the performance-pay model in upcoming salary decisions.

Further reading

For more on how district leaders run schools, see Administration.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Chron.

Live Poll

Should local school districts pay teachers based on performance rather than years of experience?