Appeals Court Reverses $250,000 Default Judgment

A Houston apartment complex wins reversal of a default judgment over a former tenant's allegedly removed belongings, with the case sent back to the trial court.

Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Apartments

Appeals Court Reverses $250,000 Default Judgment

Live Poll

Do you trust local landlords to respond fairly when tenants bring legal claims?

The First Court of Appeals reversed a default judgment of roughly $250,000 against a Houston apartment complex in a suit brought by former tenant Kimberly Aguilera over alleged removal of her belongings. The case was remanded to the trial court.

Why it matters

The ruling turns on whether the complex was properly served, a question that determines whether a default judgment can stand when a defendant says it never received notice of the suit. The outcome underscores how service and notice procedures can decide civil disputes between tenants and property operators in Houston.

The default judgment itemized $164,347.77 in economic damages, $81,516.38 in mental-anguish damages and $4,135.85 in attorney fees, and the appellate court's reversal sends the case back to the trial court for further proceedings. Whether the complex was validly served with the June 7, 2024 citation remains the central contested point.

The players

First Court of Appeals

The Texas intermediate appellate court based in Houston that hears civil appeals from the trial courts in its district, including Harris County.

The details

Former tenant Kimberly Aguilera sued the Houston apartment complex, alleging her jewelry, clothing, furniture and other belongings were removed after she left in August 2023. The complex did not answer or appear, and the trial court entered a default judgment; the complex now argues service was defective on the face of the record and that it learned of the suit only long after the judgment, and it filed a notice of restricted appeal.

Timeline

  1. April 1, 2023: Aguilera began her tenancy under a one-year lease.

  2. August 2023: Aguilera left the apartment, and the alleged removal of belongings followed.

  3. June 7, 2024: A deputy constable filed a return indicating service of citation.

  4. November 6, 2026: The First Court of Appeals reversed the default judgment and remanded the case.

Legal Context

The reversal follows Texas's established rule that a default judgment is set aside on restricted appeal where service is defective on the face of the record, a standard that gives defendants who never received notice a path to challenge large awards. The case shows how service questions can outweigh the underlying merits in tenant-landlord litigation.

Tenants who move out and believe belongings were removed may need to check service and notice records carefully, since a default judgment can be set aside on appeal. Renters should keep copies of leases, move-out documentation and any inventory of personal property.

The takeaway

Courts can set aside default judgments when service is defective on the record, so both landlords and tenants should document notice and move-out steps carefully. Keeping written records of leases, property inventories and service of process can decide whether a dispute is heard on its merits.

Further reading

Explore more apartment rental news to see how tenant disputes like this one play out across the Houston rental market.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Legal Newsline.

Live Poll

Do you trust local landlords to respond fairly when tenants bring legal claims?