Brandon Aubrey Missed Crucial Extra Point Attempt
The Dallas Cowboys kicker failed to convert a 48-yard point-after attempt following a taunting penalty.
Updated on Sept. 18, 2026 in Football
Live Poll
Should professional athletes be held accountable for mental errors during high-pressure games?
Dallas Cowboys kicker Brandon Aubrey missed a 48-yard extra point attempt during the team's Week 1 loss to the New York Giants. The attempt was moved back significantly due to a taunting penalty called during a touchdown reception.
Why it matters
The miss highlights the impact of situational penalties on special teams execution, as the penalty forced a shift in strategy from a potential 2-point conversion to a longer-range extra point.
Aubrey previously went 10-for-10 on kicks between 40 and 49 yards during the last season, marking a significant deviation from his usual accuracy. He also recorded a missed 57-yard field goal in the regular season finale against the Giants last season.
The players
Brandon Aubrey
He is the placekicker for the Dallas Cowboys who has established a reputation for high accuracy on mid-range field goals.
Brian Schottenheimer
He serves as a coach who oversaw the strategic decision-making process regarding the extra point attempt.
Javonte Williams
He is a player whose taunting penalty during a touchdown reception influenced the game's special teams strategy.
Dallas Cowboys
This is a professional American football team that competes in the National Football League.
New York Giants
This is a professional American football team based in the New York metropolitan area.
The details
A taunting penalty against Javonte Williams during a touchdown play pushed the ball back, leading coach Brian Schottenheimer to abandon a 2-point conversion attempt in favor of an extra point. The delay and increased distance impacted the kick, with reports noting the kicker struggled to find the necessary rhythm following the disruption.
Timeline
Last season, Aubrey missed a 57-yard field goal attempt.
On September 13, 2026, Aubrey missed the 48-yard extra point during the Week 1 game.
Season Trajectory
This miss complicates the Dallas Cowboys' early-season momentum as they look to establish stability within a competitive division. It serves as a reminder that even highly accurate kickers face risks when game-changing penalties alter standard scoring strategy.
The missed point-after attempt proved costly in an eight-point game, directly impacting the final scoring margin against the Giants. Fantasy managers should monitor whether this miss leads to any adjustments in coaching trust regarding longer-distance conversion attempts.
The takeaway
Special teams execution remains a critical variable that can shift based on situational penalties and timing delays. Maintaining focus through disruption is essential for kickers to uphold their career accuracy standards.
Further reading
For more on the team's performance, visit the Football section.
Live Poll
Should professional athletes be held accountable for mental errors during high-pressure games?
