Court Says Ex-UT Austin President Can Be Sued
A Fifth Circuit panel ruled that Jay Hartzell, former president of the University of Texas at Austin, is not shielded from individual liability in a discrimination case.
Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Politics

Live Poll
Should university leaders be personally liable for discrimination in pay decisions?
A Fifth Circuit panel ruled that former University of Texas at Austin president Jay Hartzell can be held individually liable in a discrimination lawsuit brought by two professors. The professors allege they were denied pay raises because they are Hispanic, and the court found they plausibly alleged Hartzell was personally involved in those decisions.
Why it matters
The ruling means Hartzell is not entitled to qualified immunity at this stage, allowing the claims to proceed against him personally rather than only against the university. For Austin and the wider Texas higher-education community, it highlights how individual administrators can be held accountable for pay decisions.
The Fifth Circuit's ruling is an unpublished opinion, meaning it does not set binding precedent, and the underlying discrimination claims remain pending. Whether the professors can prove that Hispanic identity drove the denied raises has not yet been decided.
The players
Jay Hartzell
Jay Hartzell is the president of Southern Methodist University in Dallas and the former president of the University of Texas at Austin, the defendant in the discrimination suit.
University of Texas at Austin
The University of Texas at Austin is a public research university in Austin, Texas, and the institution where the disputed pay decisions were made.
The details
The professors allege they were denied pay raises because they are Hispanic. The panel, made up of Judges Catharina Haynes and Irma Carrillo Ramirez with a dissent, concluded Hartzell is not entitled to qualified immunity, and that the disparate treatment claims over the denied raises remain alive.
Timeline
November 19, 2026: Fifth Circuit panel issues ruling that Hartzell can be held individually liable.
Legal Context
The decision turns on whether public officials can be sued personally under the Fourteenth Amendment-based framework that qualified immunity governs. It extends individual liability questions that have arisen for public employers into the context of university pay-setting.
For faculty and staff at public universities in Texas, the ruling signals that administrators who personally set pay may face individual lawsuits. Employees who believe they were denied raises for discriminatory reasons may see this case as a precedent for pursuing claims against decision-makers.
The takeaway
Public employees alleging discriminatory pay decisions can, in some circumstances, pursue claims against the individual officials who made them rather than only the institution. Tracking how courts apply qualified immunity in employment cases is useful for anyone following academic workplace disputes.
Further reading
For related rulings on public officials and civil rights, see our Law coverage.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Bloomberglaw.
Live Poll
Should university leaders be personally liable for discrimination in pay decisions?






