Fifth Circuit Denies Lucid Rehearing on Texas Sales Ban

The appeals court declined to reconsider its ruling that keeps Texas's ban on manufacturer-direct vehicle sales in place.

Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in Law

Fifth Circuit Denies Lucid Rehearing on Texas Sales Ban

Live Poll

Should car buyers be allowed to purchase new vehicles directly from manufacturers?

On October 7, 2026, the Fifth Circuit denied Lucid Group USA's request for rehearing en banc in Lucid Group USA, Inc. v. Johnston. The ruling leaves in place a September 4, 2026 panel decision that affirmed summary judgment for Texas officials and the Texas Automobile Dealers Association.

Why it matters

The decision means Texas can continue barring Lucid from selling vehicles directly to consumers through manufacturer-owned studios, a restriction that affects how the company can operate in the state. Lucid has no franchised dealers, so the ban shapes its entire Texas sales model.

The Fifth Circuit denied rehearing en banc on October 7, 2026, and the case is now in the period before any certiorari petition is filed. Lucid's ordinary deadline to seek Supreme Court review is 90 days after entry of judgment, and the company has not yet said whether it will file.

The players

Lucid Group USA, Inc.

Lucid Group is a California-based electric vehicle manufacturer that sells its cars directly to consumers rather than through franchised dealers.

Texas Automobile Dealers Association

The Texas Automobile Dealers Association is the trade group representing franchised new-car dealers in Texas, which backed the state's direct-sales restrictions in court.

The details

The Fifth Circuit first treated Lucid's en banc petition as a request for panel rehearing and summarily denied it, stating that no panel member or active judge had requested a poll. Chief Judge Elrod and Judge Higginbotham concurred dubitante with the September decision, questioning whether Fifth Circuit precedent should apply to Lucid's as-applied challenge even though they viewed it as controlling.

Timeline

  1. September 4, 2026: Fifth Circuit panel affirmed summary judgment for Texas officials and the Texas Automobile Dealers Association.

  2. October 7, 2026: Fifth Circuit denied Lucid's request for rehearing en banc.

Legal Context

The ruling keeps in force Texas's franchise-dealer framework, which bars manufacturers from selling directly to buyers and remains a major point of conflict between electric-vehicle makers and state dealer associations. Lucid's challenge tests whether that framework can be applied against a manufacturer that has no franchised dealers at all.

Texas buyers cannot purchase a Lucid vehicle directly from the manufacturer in the state and must go through the company's current arrangements under the ban. Any change to that access would depend on a further court decision or a change in state law.

The takeaway

The case shows how state franchise laws can limit new automakers' sales models even after a federal court has reviewed them. Readers following the dispute should watch whether Lucid seeks Supreme Court review within the 90-day window.

Further reading

For related coverage of state court and legal disputes, see Law in our politics section.

Source note: This article includes information reported by The National Law Review - A Free To Use Nationwide Database of Legal Publications.

Live Poll

Should car buyers be allowed to purchase new vehicles directly from manufacturers?