Appeals Court Reverses $1.7M Verdict Against Railroad

The 14th Court of Appeals of Texas found insufficient evidence for the total damages awarded to a Union Pacific employee injured in a utility vehicle crash.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Crime

Appeals Court Reverses $1.7M Verdict Against Railroad

The 14th Court of Appeals of Texas reversed a $1,732,000 jury verdict against United Pacific Railroad and remanded the case for a new trial on the negligence claim, excluding mental anguish damages. The appeal concerned a UPR employee who was a passenger in a Kawasaki Mule when its driver, also a UPR employee, hopped a curb and collided with a building.

Why it matters

The ruling sends the negligence claim back for retrial and questions whether the evidence supported the jury's full damages award. It shows how appellate courts can separately review liability and the size of damages in workplace injury cases.

The 14th Court of Appeals of Texas reversed the jury's total damages award and remanded the negligence claim for a new trial, excluding past and future mental anguish. The retrial's outcome and the amount of any new damages remain undetermined.

The players

United Pacific Railroad

A railroad company that was the defendant in the case and whose employees were involved in the Mule crash. It is a major freight rail operator in the United States.

The details

Travis Gozan was riding as a passenger in a Kawasaki Mule, a low-speed utility vehicle, wearing a seatbelt when the driver lost control and struck a building. Gozan went to the emergency room with lower back pain, headache, blurred vision and shoulder tightness, but his physical examination was unremarkable and his primary doctor cleared him to return to work in two weeks.

Timeline

  1. Nov. 10, 2026: The 14th Court of Appeals of Texas issued its opinion reversing the verdict.

Legal Context

The decision applies Texas appellate review of whether the evidence supports each category of a jury's damages award, a standard that can reduce a verdict without disturbing liability findings. Cases like this illustrate how workplace injury suits against railroads are often narrowed on appeal even when liability is contested.

Employees injured in workplace accidents may face lengthy litigation before damages are finally settled, and appellate courts can reduce awards even after a jury rules for them. Railroad workers and others riding in work vehicles should understand that a verdict can be partly overturned on appeal.

The takeaway

A jury verdict is not final until appeals are resolved, and damages can be reduced even when liability is upheld. Workers hurt in accidents should keep records of medical care and return-to-work guidance, since those details shape how damages are judged.

Further reading

For similar workplace injury litigation, see Accidents coverage across Texas.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Legal Newsline.