McCallie Declines Elite Football Arms Race
The Chattanooga school says it will not build a super-elite roster amid shifting NIL rules, transfer flexibility and league disparities.
Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Football

Live Poll
Do you think high school football should prioritize winning or character development?
McCallie School announced its position on November 16, 2025, stating it will not pursue a super-elite football team as talent concentration grows across its Division II league. Four league schools opted out of the league schedule and forfeited post-season play for the next two years.
Why it matters
The announcement reflects a split over how high school football should operate as Name, Image and Likeness policies, residency requirements and transfer rules change. McCallie plans to work with like-minded independent schools in Tennessee to set higher standards.
McCallie has won five state championships in the past seven years, a record it attributes to its existing program rather than recruiting. Four Division II league schools have forfeited post-season play for the next two years.
The players
McCallie School
A Chattanooga independent school whose football program competes in a Division II league.
Lee Burns
Head of School at McCallie School who outlined the institution's position on football and athletics changes.
The details
Head of School Lee Burns outlined the position in an announcement on Monday. The school says it works with Athletic Director Kenny Sholl and head coach Joel Bradford and does not pursue college-style recruiting or buy talent.
Timeline
November 16, 2025: McCallie announces its position on football and athletics changes.
Next two years: Four league schools forfeit post-season play.
Season Trajectory
McCallie's refusal to chase an elite roster comes as NIL rules and transfer flexibility reshape how talent is distributed in high school football. The league's split, with four schools forfeiting post-season play, suggests competitive balance concerns are now affecting the postseason itself.
The four forfeited post-season slots over the next two years change which Chattanooga-area teams can compete for titles in the league. Fans tracking the league should expect fewer postseason matchups until the forfeiture period ends.
The takeaway
Schools that decline to chase talent may keep their identity but could face a narrower competitive path while rivals reshape their rosters. Families evaluating high school football programs should ask how each school recruits and manages transfers.
Further reading
Explore more Football coverage for context on how roster-building debates are playing out across the sport.
Live Poll
Do you think high school football should prioritize winning or character development?










