Tennessee Court Upholds Hotel Deal Deposit Forfeiture
The state Supreme Court ruled that a contract's agreed damages clause is enforceable, ending a buyer's bid to recover its earnest money.
Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Commercial

The Tennessee Supreme Court unanimously reversed the Court of Appeals and upheld summary judgment for a hotel seller that kept an $18,917,500 earnest money deposit after a buyer failed to close in January 2020. The court held that a damages provision the parties agreed would be hard to calculate is presumed enforceable as liquidated damages.
Why it matters
The ruling reinforces that parties who expressly agree to a liquidated damages clause face a presumption of enforceability, and a challenger must show the amount is an unenforceable penalty. For commercial real estate deals, it signals that deposits can be kept when a buyer defaults and the contract anticipated the harm.
The court's decision rested on a contract provision acknowledging that damages would be difficult to ascertain, with the earnest money totaling $18,917,500 after twenty-four amendments. The record does not indicate what the seller's actual losses were or whether they were calculated.
The players
Tennessee Supreme Court
The state's highest court, which issues final rulings on questions of Tennessee law, including contract enforceability.
The details
A buyer agreed in October 2019 to purchase a Nashville-area hotel near the airport, then failed to close in January 2020, and the seller terminated the contract and kept the deposit. The buyer sued in Davidson County more than two years later, and the trial court sided with the seller before the Court of Appeals reversed, a decision the Supreme Court then overturned.
Timeline
October 2019: the hotel purchase contract was signed.
January 2020: the buyer failed to close and the seller terminated.
More than two years after January 2020: the buyer filed suit in Davidson County.
November 16, 2026: the Tennessee Supreme Court released its opinion.
Market Context
The decision applies Tennessee's established liquidated damages doctrine, which presumes enforceability when parties agreed in advance that actual damages would be hard to measure. It confirms that commercial deposits in large real estate transactions can be retained when the contract contemplated the harm.
Buyers signing commercial purchase contracts in Tennessee should understand that an agreed damages clause can allow the seller to keep a deposit after default. Those who negotiate closing extensions and deposit increases should weigh how much of that money is at risk if they cannot close.
The takeaway
Read a contract's default and damages terms before depositing earnest money, since a liquidated damages clause can make a deposit non-refundable. Consulting a real estate attorney before amending a purchase agreement repeatedly can help you understand the exposure.
Further reading
For related coverage of deal terms and property transactions, see Commercial real estate in our Tennessee section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Chattanoogan.










