Appeals Court Revives Challenge to Tennessee Buffer Law

A federal appeals panel ordered a judge to reconsider media organizations' bid to block the state's 25-foot police buffer law.

Updated on Nov. 13, 2026 in Legislative Policy

Appeals Court Revives Challenge to Tennessee Buffer Law

Live Poll

Should police be able to order the public and reporters 25 feet back from scenes?

The 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ordered U.S. District Judge William Campbell Jr. to reconsider a media coalition's injunction request against Tennessee's buffer law. The law, passed in May 2025, lets law enforcement order people, including reporters, to stay 25 feet from crime scenes, traffic stops and ongoing threats to public safety.

Why it matters

The panel found reporters face a choice between defying a police order under threat of criminal punishment or stopping First Amendment-protected activity, a dispute that bears directly on newsgathering in Tennessee. The ruling sends the question of whether the plaintiffs are likely to succeed back to the district court.

The Sixth Circuit panel sent the injunction request back to U.S. District Judge William Campbell Jr., who had ruled in February that the law stays in effect while the suit proceeds. The media coalition's First Amendment and vagueness claims have not yet been decided on the merits.

The players

Memphis Safe Task Force

A coalition of federal and state agencies formed by the Trump administration to address public safety in Memphis, Tennessee.

William Campbell Jr.

A U.S. District Judge in Nashville who presides over the lawsuit challenging Tennessee's buffer law.

Mark Pody

A Tennessee state senator who said the law was intended to protect the work of law enforcement during the legislative session.

The details

The coalition, including Tennessee Lookout, Nashville Banner, Gannett, Scripps Media and TEGNA, sued in late May 2025, arguing the law is vague and blocks newsgathering. The panel found the media organizations have standing at this stage and that Campbell did not consider whether the plaintiffs were likely to succeed. The Memphis Safe Task Force, a group of federal and state agencies, has invoked the law several times, including to keep officers' activities out of view.

Timeline

  1. May 2025: Tennessee's General Assembly passed the buffer law.

  2. Late May 2025: The media coalition filed its lawsuit.

  3. February 2026: Judge Campbell ruled the law remains in effect during the lawsuit.

  4. November 10, 2026: The 6th Circuit panel ordered reconsideration of the injunction request.

Legislative Policy

Similar police buffer laws were struck down in Indiana and Louisiana, and the Tennessee case now tests whether courts there will follow that pattern. The outcome will shape how far states can go in restricting observers near police activity.

Journalists and members of the public in Tennessee may be ordered to stay 25 feet from crime scenes and traffic stops while the lawsuit proceeds. Violating the order can result in a misdemeanor charge, which affects how observers and reporters can document police activity.

The takeaway

Whether Tennessee's buffer law survives will depend on how the district court weighs the likelihood that the media plaintiffs succeed on their First Amendment claim. Residents who observe police work should understand the 25-foot rule currently in effect.

Further reading

For related coverage, see Legislative Policy in Tennessee politics.

Live Poll

Should police be able to order the public and reporters 25 feet back from scenes?