Tennessee Playoff System Draws Criticism Over Losing Teams
Hamilton County school board member Steve Slater says the state's nine football championships and playoff format are insane.
Updated on Nov. 11, 2026 in Football

Live Poll
Should high school football playoffs include teams with losing records?
Hamilton County School Board member Steve Slater called Tennessee's nine high school football championships insane. Ten schools with losing records were eligible for the playoffs, and Red Boiling Springs forfeited its playoff game against South Pittsburg over player safety concerns.
Why it matters
The Tennessee playoffs started with 44 teams with losing records, raising questions about competitive balance and player safety. Slater heads the county schools athletic committee, and the forfeit has left Red Boiling Springs ineligible for the playoffs for the next two seasons.
Ten schools with losing records were eligible for the playoffs, and the postseason opened with 44 such teams. Red Boiling Springs paid South Pittsburg $2,000 after forfeiting, and it is ineligible for the next two seasons.
The players
Steve Slater
Slater is a Hamilton County School Board member who heads the county schools athletic committee.
The details
Under the current format, the top four teams in each region advance regardless of record. Red Boiling Springs, which finished 0-10, was scheduled to play South Pittsburg but forfeited, citing player safety concerns, and paid South Pittsburg $2,000. Brainerd also forfeited to Tyner in regional play after falling short of players, and Central forfeited a playoff game last season after dropping to 23 available players.
Timeline
Last season: Central forfeited a playoff game after dropping to 23 available players.
Recent board committee meeting: Slater called Tennessee's nine championships insane.
Season Trajectory
Tennessee's region format lets the top four teams in each region qualify regardless of record, which has put 44 losing-record teams into this year's playoffs. Compared with Georgia and Florida, which have eight championships each, and Texas, which has twelve, Tennessee's playoff structure is now drawing scrutiny over how it balances competitiveness and player safety.
Red Boiling Springs cannot play in the playoffs for the next two seasons, which affects its schedule and roster planning. The format allowing four teams per region to advance regardless of record directly determines which teams fans and fantasy players will see in postseason games.
The takeaway
The playoff format's forfeits and losing-record qualifiers show how regional rules can shape both competition and player safety. Readers following Tennessee high school football should watch for any changes to eligibility or the four-team advancement rule.
Further reading
For more on the state's postseason rules, see the Tennessee Football section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Chattanoogan.
Live Poll
Should high school football playoffs include teams with losing records?






