AME Church Retirees Can Recoup Part of $44.4M

Clergy and staff may recover portions of a $44.4 million settlement tied to alleged misappropriation of retirement funds.

Updated on Nov. 2, 2026 in Retirement Planning

AME Church Retirees Can Recoup Part of $44.4M

The AME Church Department of Retirement Services announced in an October 19 email that participants can recoup part of a $44.4 million settlement, with funds transferred by wire and now available for distribution. The settlement is part of a case that has recovered $106.2 million in total.

Why it matters

The payments restore a portion of retirement savings that plaintiffs say were lost through alleged mismanagement, which early in the litigation was estimated at $88.4 million. For Tennessee retirees and clergy affected by the case, the distributions represent a concrete step toward recovering funds.

Account balances were restored to about 61.5 percent of the June 30, 2021 statement balance, and the $44.4 million Symetra settlement sits within a total of $106.2 million recovered in the case. Plaintiffs argue balances should have been about $227 million, and how that gap is resolved remains unclear.

The players

AME Church Department of Retirement Services

The denominational office that administers retirement plans for clergy and staff of the African Methodist Episcopal Church and announced the distribution.

Symetra Life Insurance Co.

The insurance company that agreed to the settlement and declined to comment on the announcement.

Jerome Harris

The former director of the AME Church's retirement department, who retired in 2021 and died in 2024 of a heart attack.

The details

A federal judge approved a settlement in August between a class of retirement plan participants and Symetra Life Insurance Co., and in April had given preliminary approval for participants to recover an additional $44.4 million. The plaintiffs allege Symetra conspired with Jerome Harris, former director of the Department of Retirement Services, in misappropriating funds; the AME Church was not a party to that settlement, and Symetra declined to comment.

Timeline

  1. 2021: Plaintiffs discovered alleged mismanagement, and Harris retired.

  2. 2025: A federal judge approved more than $60 million in partial settlements involving about 4,500 people.

  3. April: Preliminary approval was granted for the additional $44.4 million Symetra settlement.

  4. August: A federal judge approved the Symetra settlement.

  5. October 19: The Department of Retirement Services announced settlement funds are available for distribution.

Legal Context

Following more than $60 million in partial settlements approved by a federal judge in 2025, the $44.4 million Symetra recovery extends the Western District of Tennessee litigation toward a $106.2 million total. The case illustrates how class recoveries in retirement plan mismanagement suits are typically paid out in stages as separate defendants settle.

Eligible clergy and staff may see restored balances in their retirement accounts, which can affect long-term savings planning. Because legal fees will take one-third of the $44.4 million total, participants should expect distributions to be net of those costs.

The takeaway

Retirees affected by plan mismanagement should review their account statements and any distribution notices to confirm the restored balance. Watching for court filings on balance recalculations can help clarify whether further recovery is possible.

What happens next

Plaintiffs may need to file a motion about how balances were recalculated and how plans are administered, and legal fees are expected to total one-third of the $44.4 million settlement.

Further reading

For more on how retirement plan recoveries are handled, see Retirement Planning coverage.

Source note: This article includes information reported by The Christian Century.