South Dakota Reissues About 400 Vanity Plates

A 2023 ACLU lawsuit settlement led the state to reconsider plates it had previously rejected as offensive.

Updated on Nov. 13, 2026 in Law

Bold vector editorial illustration of a blank rectangular metal plate-blank with a rounded notch on a flat coral and teal field, evoking revised vanity-plate policy.
South Dakota's Motor Vehicles Division has issued about 400 personalized license plates it had previously rejected since December 2023, after an ACLU lawsuit settlement. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should state governments limit what offensive messages drivers can put on license plates?

South Dakota has authorized about 400 previously denied personalized license plates since December 2023, following a settlement of a federal lawsuit brought by the American Civil Liberties Union of South Dakota. The state's Motor Vehicles Division had rejected 673 of 2,135 applications received between June 2018 and July 2023 for offensiveness to good taste and decency.

Why it matters

The case highlights how government discretion over personalized plates, which previously relied on dictionary definitions and internet searches, can produce arbitrary outcomes. The ACLU argued that the state's standards allowed arbitrary censorship, and the revised policy now relies on a defined dictionary standard instead.

The Motor Vehicles Division rejected 673 of 2,135 personalized plate applications between June 2018 and July 2023 for offending good taste and decency. Records do not show how many of the roughly 400 reissued plates were requested by reapplicants or whether later rejections have occurred under the revised policy.

The players

South Dakota Department of Revenue Motor Vehicles Division

The state agency responsible for issuing vehicle registrations and personalized license plates, which rejected the applications and revised its review standards. The division operates under the state's Department of Revenue.

American Civil Liberties Union of South Dakota

The state affiliate of the national civil liberties organization that filed the federal lawsuit challenging the state's plate standards as arbitrary censorship. It is part of the ACLU's nationwide network of litigation and advocacy groups.

The details

The lawsuit was filed in November 2023 on behalf of Lyndon Hart, whose application for the plate REZWEED had been rejected, and the department approved that plate before the case was settled in December 2023. The settlement allowed anyone whose application had been rejected to reapply, and the department had already revised its policy in September 2023 to remove the general prohibition on language offensive to good taste and decency.

Timeline

  1. June 2018 to July 2023: Motor Vehicles Division received 2,135 personalized plate applications.

  2. September 2023: The department revised its personalized plate policy.

  3. November 2023: The ACLU of South Dakota filed a federal lawsuit on behalf of Lyndon Hart.

  4. December 2023: The lawsuit was settled and rejected applicants were allowed to reapply.

  5. Since December 2023: About 400 previously denied vanity plates have been authorized.

Political Context

The ACLU argued that South Dakota's standards allowed arbitrary censorship by government officials relying on dictionary definitions and internet searches. The state's shift to a defined Merriam-Webster standard addresses that objection but leaves open whether similar challenges will continue in other states.

Drivers in South Dakota who previously had a personalized plate request rejected may now reapply under the settlement terms. The revised policy applies a published dictionary standard, so applicants can check their requested wording against Merriam-Webster before submitting an application.

The takeaway

Government standards for personalized plates are only as predictable as the rules written to govern them, and this settlement shows that defined criteria can replace case-by-case judgment. Residents interested in a custom plate can review the published standard before applying.

Further reading

For related coverage of court rulings and legal disputes, browse the Law section on the South Dakota politics page.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Sioux Falls Live.

Live Poll

Should state governments limit what offensive messages drivers can put on license plates?