Irmo Fire Offers Settlement in Firefighter Death Suit

The Irmo Fire District seeks dismissal of claims tied to the 2023 death of firefighter James Michael Muller in a Columbia apartment collapse.

Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Crime

Irmo Fire Offers Settlement in Firefighter Death Suit

The Irmo Fire District filed a settlement offer November 16 in Richland County Common Pleas Court in a lawsuit over the death of firefighter James Michael Muller, 25, who was killed when a building collapsed during a fire at the Tropical Ridge apartment complex in Columbia. The offer seeks dismissal of all claims against the district and calls for the firing of Columbia-Richland Fire Chief Aubrey Jenkins and Assistant Chief Anthony Holloway, along with written apologies.

Why it matters

The lawsuit was filed by Muller's widow, Emma Elizabeth Muller, against the city of Columbia and Richland County, and the city has brought the Irmo Fire District in as a third-party defendant. The filing states the offer is not an admission of liability and was made to avoid the costs of continued litigation.

The settlement offer seeks $40,296 in legal fees and costs and gives recipients 20 days to respond. It remains unclear whether the city, the county, or Muller's estate will accept the terms.

The players

Irmo Fire District

The Irmo Fire District is the fire protection agency serving Irmo, South Carolina, and is a third-party defendant in the lawsuit.

Aubrey Jenkins

Aubrey Jenkins is the Columbia-Richland Fire Chief, the fire department leader named in the settlement offer's firing demand.

Anthony Holloway

Anthony Holloway is the Assistant Chief of the Columbia-Richland Fire Department, named in the settlement offer.

The details

The settlement offer requires written apologies from Jenkins and Holloway for publication in The State and The Post and Courier within 30 days of acceptance. Jenkins is asked to apologize over allegations that Irmo Fire or its employees gave false statements to investigating agencies, and Holloway over an allegation that a Columbia-area safety researcher wrote a NIOSH report; the district describes those allegations as false.

Timeline

  1. May 26, 2023: Muller was killed when a building collapsed during the Tropical Ridge apartment fire.

  2. April 2025: A NIOSH report was released citing communication and structural risk failures.

  3. November 16, 2026: The Irmo Fire District filed its settlement offer in Richland County court.

Legal Context

The settlement offer follows the Tropical Ridge collapse of May 2023, which killed firefighter James Michael Muller and produced a NIOSH report in April 2025. The lawsuit now turns on whether the city of Columbia and Richland County can shift responsibility to the Irmo Fire District through third-party claims.

Residents of Columbia and Irmo may see the outcome of this suit shape how local fire agencies handle communication and safety reviews after deadly incidents. The case may also affect how responsibility is divided among municipalities when public employees are injured or killed on the job.

The takeaway

Public accountability after on-duty deaths often plays out through civil litigation and agency reviews, not only through official findings. Readers following the case can track the court docket in Richland County Common Pleas Court for any response to the offer.

Further reading

Explore more Columbia accident coverage for related local reporting.

Source note: This article includes information reported by WACH.