Appeals Court Upholds FACE Act Conviction in Columbia

The Fourth Circuit affirmed a 60-day sentence for blocking a Columbia, South Carolina, reproductive health clinic entrance.

Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Sex Crimes

Appeals Court Upholds FACE Act Conviction in Columbia

The Fourth Circuit affirmed the conviction of a Columbia, South Carolina man under the FACE Act for blocking the entrance to a reproductive health clinic in November 2022. The court held the offense is presumptively petty and that the defendant had no Sixth Amendment right to a jury trial.

Why it matters

The ruling clarifies that FACE Act obstruction charges carrying a six-month maximum can be tried without a jury, a point that shapes how similar cases proceed in Columbia and across the Fourth Circuit. It also confirms that the government may amend a penalty sheet without returning the matter to a grand jury.

The Fourth Circuit affirmed the district court's judgment, leaving the 60-day imprisonment and $1,000 fine in place. The court did not address whether further appeal will be sought.

The players

Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals

The federal appellate court covering Maryland, North Carolina, South Carolina, Virginia and West Virginia, which reviews rulings from federal district courts in those states.

The details

The defendant blocked the entrance to a Columbia reproductive health clinic in November 2022 and refused to move when asked to leave, leading to his arrest and indictment under the FACE Act. The government amended the penalty sheet to the first-time, nonviolent physical obstruction provision, and the defendant consented to the change while objecting to proceeding without a jury.

Timeline

  1. November 2022: Defendant blocked the clinic entrance during an anti-abortion protest in Columbia.

  2. November 15, 2026: The Fourth Circuit published its decision affirming the conviction.

Legal Context

The decision applies the FACE Act of 1994, which Congress enacted to protect access to reproductive health facilities, and follows Supreme Court precedent separating petty offenses from serious ones by maximum authorized imprisonment. It extends that framework to a federal obstruction charge in South Carolina.

Residents and clinic staff in Columbia may see continued enforcement of FACE Act obstruction charges against protesters blocking clinic entrances. The ruling confirms that such misdemeanor-level cases can proceed without a jury trial.

The takeaway

Federal courts treat obstruction charges carrying a six-month maximum as petty offenses, which can shorten the path to resolution for these cases. Readers following clinic-access enforcement in South Carolina can track how the Fourth Circuit applies this standard in future rulings.

Further reading

Explore more Sex Crimes coverage in Columbia for related legal developments.

Source note: This article includes information reported by South Carolina Lawyers Weekly.