State Moves to Dismiss Suit Over Second-Home Tax
Rhode Island has asked a court to throw out a challenge from more than 50 property owners to its tax on second homes.
Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Law

Live Poll
Should states be allowed to tax second homes owned by non-residents?
Rhode Island filed motions to dismiss a lawsuit from more than 50 owners of property subject to its second-home tax, which the owners sued over in Newport County Superior Court in August. The state filed the motions on Friday.
Why it matters
The suit argues the tax unlawfully discriminates against non-residents and is unreasonably selective under federal and state constitutions. The state argues the lawsuit is an effort to hamstring the legislature's taxing power, so the outcome could shape how the state can tax second homes in Rhode Island.
More than 50 property owners brought the suit, and no ruling has yet been issued on the state's motions to dismiss. The court's decision on whether the case can proceed remains pending.
The players
State of Rhode Island
Rhode Island is a New England state whose legislature enacted the second-home tax and whose government is defending it in court.
The details
The owners allege the second-home tax is unlawfully discriminatory against non-residents and unreasonably selective, both under federal and state constitutions. The lawsuit seeks a court declaration that the levy is unlawful, and the state's filing asks the court to dismiss the case.
Timeline
August 2026: More than 50 property owners filed suit in Newport County Superior Court.
Friday, November 13, 2026: The state filed motions to dismiss the lawsuit.
Legal Context
The suit tests whether Rhode Island's second-home tax can withstand federal and state constitutional challenges claiming discrimination against non-residents. Its outcome will show how far the legislature's taxing power extends over property owned by people who do not live in the state.
Owners of second homes in Rhode Island face the uncertainty of an unresolved challenge to the tax. If the court rules against the state, the tax could be struck down or altered, changing what these owners pay.
The takeaway
Tax disputes over property owned by non-residents often turn on constitutional limits, so the court's ruling on the motions to dismiss will be the first signal of how this challenge proceeds.
Further reading
Explore more on Rhode Island law and how state courts handle constitutional tax challenges.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Bloombergtax.
Live Poll
Should states be allowed to tax second homes owned by non-residents?










