Pittsburgh Police Review Board Seats Stay Vacant
The Citizen Police Review Board has had no law enforcement representatives and two empty seats for months, according to its executive director.
Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Law Enforcement

Live Poll
Do you trust Pittsburgh's city leaders to fill public board seats promptly?
The Pittsburgh Citizen Police Review Board has no law enforcement representatives and two vacant seats, with Executive Director Elizabeth Pittinger urging city leaders to fill them. Former members Sheldon Williams and Karen Dixon left after taking city jobs, which disqualified them from serving on the board.
Why it matters
The board investigates citizen complaints about officers, and it has received 217 complaints so far this year. Keeping its seats filled affects how those complaints are reviewed and how the board is balanced between council and mayoral appointees.
The board is operating with two of its seven seats empty, and the extraction does not state whether any complaint reviews have been delayed. City Council has not yet submitted a list of three nominees for the mayor-appointed selection process, and the proposed 2027 board budget is just over $1 million.
The players
Elizabeth Pittinger
Elizabeth Pittinger is the executive director of the Pittsburgh Citizen Police Review Board, which investigates complaints from residents about city police officers.
Anthony Coghill
Anthony Coghill is a Pittsburgh City Councilman who co-recommended John Fisher for the council-appointed board seat.
John Fisher
John Fisher is a former Zone 3 Commander of the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police who was recommended by council members for a board seat.
The details
Council members Bob Charland, Anthony Coghill and Kim Salinetro recommended former Zone 3 Commander John Fisher in July, and a City Clerk memorandum from Kimberly Clark-Baskin urged council to submit three nominees to the mayor. Under the board's structure, two seats are reserved for people with law enforcement experience, one from each appointing group, and both reserved seats are currently unfilled.
Timeline
June: Karen Dixon left the board after Mayor appointed her assistant chief of administration.
July: Council members recommended John Fisher and the City Clerk sent a nominee memorandum.
November 19, 2026: Executive Director Elizabeth Pittinger raised the vacancies at a budget hearing, and Anthony Coghill promised action.
Legal Context
The vacancies arise under a charter that requires two seats for people with law enforcement experience, one chosen by council and one by the mayor, a structure that ties board composition to two separate appointing authorities. Because Williams and Dixon were disqualified after taking city jobs, the seat rules now depend on the appointment sequence rather than on any single official's choice.
Residents who file complaints about Pittsburgh police officers rely on the review board to examine them, and the board's ability to do so depends on filling its vacant seats. The extraction does not say whether the vacancies have changed how quickly complaints are reviewed.
The takeaway
Residents who want police complaints handled through the review board can track whether council and the mayor move on the pending nominations. The vacancies show how a board's seat rules can stall when the appointing officials are slow to act.
Further reading
For more on how local oversight of police is organized, see Law Enforcement coverage for Pittsburgh.
Source note: This article includes information reported by TribLIVE.
Live Poll
Do you trust Pittsburgh's city leaders to fill public board seats promptly?






