Fish nor Fowl Closes Permanently in Garfield
The Garfield restaurant shut down after owner Richard DeShantz was arrested on domestic violence charges and stepped away from the restaurant group.
Updated on Nov. 3, 2026 in Dining Out

Fish nor Fowl, part of the Richard DeShantz Restaurant Group, has permanently closed, according to a closing message posted on its website on Nov. 2. The closure follows DeShantz's October arrest on domestic violence charges for allegedly assaulting his girlfriend.
Why it matters
The closure reflects the impact of legal proceedings on a restaurant group that runs more than a dozen Pittsburgh restaurants. DeShantz has stepped away from all involvement in the company while the case is ongoing.
Fish nor Fowl opened in 2018 in a Penn Avenue space that once housed Salt of the Earth and reopened on Valentine's Day 2023 after closing when the pandemic began. The Deshantz company operates more than a dozen Pittsburgh restaurants, and the closing message was posted Nov. 2.
The players
Richard DeShantz
Richard DeShantz is a Pittsburgh restaurateur whose restaurant group operates more than a dozen local restaurants.
The details
Fish nor Fowl posted a closing message on its website on Nov. 2 announcing it had permanently closed. Richard DeShantz stepped away from all involvement in the restaurant group while legal proceedings over the charges continue.
Timeline
2018: Fish nor Fowl opens in a Penn Avenue space in Garfield.
February 2023: Fish nor Fowl reopens on Valentine's Day after closing during the pandemic.
October 2026: Richard DeShantz is arrested on domestic violence charges.
Nov. 2, 2026: Fish nor Fowl posts its closing message on its website.
Market Landscape
Fish nor Fowl occupied a Penn Avenue space in Garfield that previously housed Salt of the Earth, and its closure adds to the turnover seen along that corridor. Its permanent shutdown leaves the Deshantz company with its other Pittsburgh locations as it operates without DeShantz's direct involvement.
Pittsburgh diners lose one Garfield option, and the Penn Avenue space will soon host a new concept. Patrons of other Deshantz restaurants may see changes as the group operates without DeShantz's involvement.
The takeaway
Restaurant closures can ripple beyond a single kitchen, so diners who value a favorite spot may want to follow its ownership news. Checking a restaurant's social channels or website is the most direct way to confirm changes.
What happens next
An as-yet-unnamed American dining concept is expected to open in February 2027 in the former taqueria space.
Further reading
For more on the city's restaurant scene, see Dining Out coverage in Pittsburgh.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Pittsburgh Magazine.










