Pirates Left Unsettled on Nick Gonzales Position
The Pittsburgh Pirates have yet to finalize Nick Gonzales' defensive role following a difficult 2026 season.
Updated on Sept. 30, 2026 in Baseball
Live Poll
Should your local sports team prioritize defensive reliability over offensive production when developing players?
Following a challenging transition to third base during the 2026 season, the Pittsburgh Pirates remain undecided on Nick Gonzales' permanent defensive position. The team is currently evaluating the roster while weighing potential changes for the upcoming year.
Why it matters
The team's defensive uncertainty stems from the acquisition of Brandon Lowe, which forced a move for Gonzales that resulted in significant defensive struggles. Pirates leadership is now determining whether to retain their current lineup or pursue external options at third base.
Nick Gonzales posted a .303 batting average and .755 OPS across 101 starts at third base in 2026. Conversely, Brandon Lowe started 133 games at second base while hitting 35 home runs.
The players
Nick Gonzales
He is a professional baseball player who recently completed a season transitioning to the third base position for the Pirates.
Brandon Lowe
He is a professional baseball player who joined the team to take over duties at second base during the 2026 season.
Jared Triolo
He is a utility player for the Pirates who earned a Gold Glove Award for his defensive performance in 2024.
Ben Cherington
He serves as the general manager for the Pittsburgh Pirates and is responsible for team roster decisions.
The details
The Pirates moved Gonzales to third base after acquiring Brandon Lowe to anchor the second base position. Despite his offensive production, Gonzales struggled significantly in the field, leading to ongoing exit meetings to determine his path forward.
Timeline
Jared Triolo secured a Gold Glove Award in 2024.
Gonzales experienced negative defensive metrics while playing second base in 2025.
Gonzales started 101 games at third base throughout the 2026 season.
Ben Cherington held a final press conference on September 26, 2026.
Season Trajectory
The Pirates must resolve these defensive shortcomings to improve their standing in a competitive division. Their roster decisions this offseason will dictate whether they can achieve better defensive efficiency compared to their 2026 performance.
The team's indecision impacts fantasy baseball projections for Nick Gonzales, specifically regarding his defensive eligibility for the upcoming season. Fans should monitor whether the club moves him back to second base, which would likely increase his defensive value and utility.
The takeaway
Roster versatility remains a critical factor for teams managing players who struggle with positional changes. Success for the Pirates next season depends on whether leadership chooses to prioritize defensive stability or offensive flexibility in the infield.
Further reading
For more on roster moves, visit the Pittsburgh Baseball section.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Sports Illustrated.
Live Poll
Should your local sports team prioritize defensive reliability over offensive production when developing players?
