Third Circuit Weighs Penn Harassment Case
A former teaching assistant's appeal challenges a federal court's ruling that the University of Pennsylvania was not liable.
Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Politics

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit heard oral arguments on November 18, 2025, in a sexual harassment case against the University of Pennsylvania brought by a former part-time teaching assistant. A federal district court granted summary judgment in the university's favor in October 2025, finding the plaintiff had not cited evidence a reasonable jury could use to hold the university liable.
Why it matters
The case tests how colleges in Philadelphia and across the country can be held responsible for harassment that occurs on campus and within academic work settings. A February 2026 amicus brief from the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission urging a negligence standard could shape how future claims under federal and local anti-discrimination law are decided.
The appeal is pending before the Third Circuit following the October 2025 summary judgment in favor of the University of Pennsylvania. The plaintiff's attorney has asked the appeals court to reverse the ruling and send the case back for trial.
The players
University of Pennsylvania
A private Ivy League research university in Philadelphia, founded in 1740 and among the oldest institutions of higher education in the United States.
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit
The federal appellate court covering Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware, and the U.S. Virgin Islands, which hears appeals from federal district courts in those jurisdictions.
U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
The federal agency responsible for enforcing workplace anti-discrimination laws, including Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
The details
The plaintiff, a former part-time teaching assistant to an assistant professor, alleges she was harassed by a male student and that the university failed to provide adequate remediation through its student services office. The lawsuit, filed in March 2025, alleges violations of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act and the Philadelphia Fair Practices Ordinance. A March 2023 return-to-work letter reportedly allowed the alleged harasser to interact with her in the academic setting.
Timeline
March 2023: Return-to-work letter permitted the alleged harasser to interact with the plaintiff in the academic setting.
March 2025: Lawsuit filed alleging violations of Title VII and the Philadelphia Fair Practices Ordinance.
October 2025: U.S. District Court granted summary judgment in the university's favor.
November 18, 2025: Third Circuit Court of Appeals held oral arguments.
February 2026: EEOC filed an amicus brief requesting adoption of a negligence standard.
Legal Context
The appeal tests whether the negligence standard the EEOC urges should replace the actual-knowledge requirement that governs institutional liability under Title VII. A ruling could affect how employers and universities across Pennsylvania and the Third Circuit handle harassment complaints under Title VII and the Philadelphia Fair Practices Ordinance.
For employees and students at Philadelphia institutions, the outcome could clarify what steps a university must take after a harassment complaint to avoid liability. The Third Circuit's decision may also affect how workplace harassment claims under local ordinances are litigated in the city.
The takeaway
Institutional liability for workplace harassment may turn on whether courts require proof of actual knowledge or accept a negligence standard. Employees who report harassment should document responses from their institution, since that record can matter in later litigation.
Further reading
Explore more Philadelphia legal coverage for context on local court rulings and employment law disputes.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Former Penn President Liz Magill earned $4.46 million the year following her resignation - The Daily Pennsylvanian.






