Zoning Board Rejects Taller Lancaster Avenue Project
Haverford Square Properties' 420-unit plan in Cathedral Park was denied a height variance and may be reconsidered.
Updated on Nov. 7, 2026 in Apartments
Live Poll
Should your city let large apartment projects exceed local height limits?
The Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment ruled against Haverford Square Properties this week, denying its request to exceed the height limit for a 420-unit mixed-use project on Lancaster Avenue. The developer plans to petition the board for reconsideration.
Why it matters
The ruling keeps the project's 45-foot height limit in place for the site, shaping whether the proposed apartments, commercial space and affordable units move forward in West Philadelphia. The developer says the extra height would allow higher ceilings to attract commercial tenants.
The proposal would deliver 420 apartments, including 42 affordable units, 30,000 square feet of retail space and 65 parking spaces, but the requested 51-foot height exceeds the 45-foot zoning limit. The developer's reconsideration path and the final scale of the project remain unsettled.
The players
Haverford Square Properties
The developer behind the proposed 420-unit mixed-use project on Lancaster Avenue, which is seeking to build above existing height limits.
Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment
The city board that reviews variance requests and issued the ruling denying the developer's height request.
The details
The three-building project, spanning Cathedral Yards at 5140 Lancaster Ave., Lancaster Yards at 5022-32 Lancaster Ave. and a 45-unit building at 5100 Lancaster Ave., would preserve the remaining church tower of the former Greater Bible Way Temple, which was demolished after a 2019 fire. If the ruling is final, the developer plans a version with no parking.
Timeline
2019: The Greater Bible Way Temple at 5140 Lancaster Ave. was destroyed by fire and later demolished.
October 21, 2026: The zoning board held its hearing on the project.
November 2026: The zoning board ruled against the developer this week.
Zoning Context
The denial upholds the 45-foot limit that existing zoning sets for the site, while the developer's by-right alternative would add 389 residential units with no parking. Whether the reconsideration petition changes that balance will determine how much housing the project ultimately delivers.
Residents along Lancaster Avenue will not see a 51-foot building on this site under the current ruling, keeping the scale closer to the 45-foot limit. If the by-right version proceeds, the neighborhood could gain 389 residential units with no parking and up to 4,000 square feet of commercial space.
The takeaway
Height limits and parking requirements can shift a project's unit count and affordability substantially, so ruling outcomes matter for future housing supply in the neighborhood. Watch the reconsideration petition for how the scale of the project may change.
What happens next
Haverford Square Properties plans to petition the zoning board for reconsideration of its height denial.
Further reading
For more on housing projects like this, see Apartments coverage across Philadelphia.
Source note: This article includes information reported by The Philadelphia Inquirer.
Live Poll
Should your city let large apartment projects exceed local height limits?
