Erie Times-News Names Co-Winners After Poll Error

A failed poll close and a Microsoft email outage led the paper to publish results that were not current at the poll's 5 p.m. deadline.

Updated on Nov. 16, 2026 in Football

Expressive editorial sports illustration of a lone high school football player mid-stride in side profile across an autumn practice field, with bleachers in the distance.
The Erie Times-News named Riley Wilkinson of Saegertown and Gabe Montroy of General McLane co-winners of its high school male athlete of the week poll after a failed poll close. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

The Erie Times-News has declared Riley Wilkinson of Saegertown and Gabe Montroy of General McLane co-winners of its high school male athlete of the week poll. The paper said it published results from Nov. 12 rather than the results as of 5 p.m. on Nov. 11, after the Quick Question Management System poll failed to close properly.

Why it matters

The error means the poll's published outcome did not reflect the vote at its scheduled close, affecting readers who followed the competition in Erie. The newspaper said it did not check the results at the specific closing time before publishing.

Wilkinson received 49% of votes and Montroy 47% at 5 p.m. on Nov. 11, based on the poll's intended closing time. The total number of votes cast after the intended close was not reported.

The players

Erie Times-News

The Erie, Pennsylvania daily newspaper that runs local sports polls and published the corrected co-winner declaration.

Quick Question Management System

The online polling platform used by the Erie Times-News to run its high school athlete of the week vote.

The details

The Quick Question Management System poll did not properly close at 5 p.m. on Nov. 11, and a nationwide Microsoft email crash occurred during the delayed publication period. The Times-News published Seaway Window and AHN Sports Medicine poll results on Nov. 12, with help from the poll system, and later declared the two athletes co-winners.

Timeline

  1. Nov. 11, 2026, 5 p.m.: The poll was scheduled to close but failed to close properly.

  2. Nov. 12, 2026: The Times-News published results current at that date rather than at the closing time.

  3. Nov. 16, 2026: The Erie Times-News published an apology and declared the co-winners.

Season Trajectory

Local high school athlete recognition polls like the Erie Times-News award give regional prep athletes visibility during the football season. This error changes the published outcome of a single weekly honor rather than any season standings.

The corrected co-winner declaration means both Riley Wilkinson and Gabe Montroy are recognized as athlete of the week for the poll period. Readers who relied on the Nov. 12 published results should treat the co-winner declaration as the paper's official outcome.

The takeaway

Online reader polls depend on the platform closing on schedule and on editors confirming results at the stated deadline before publication. Checking the timestamp of retrieved results can prevent publishing outdated outcomes.

Further reading

For more local prep coverage, see Football on the Erie sports pages.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Go Erie.