Ex-Job Candidate Sues University of Oregon Over Rescinded Offer

Nic Francisco-Kaho'onei alleges the university violated free speech rights by pulling a Women's Resource Center job offer over a background-check charge.

Updated on Nov. 20, 2026 in Politics

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a plain brick civic building and a blank flagpole against a dark green hillside under overcast light, evoking a quiet institutional dispute.
A former job candidate sued the University of Oregon in federal court in Eugene, alleging it violated free speech rights by rescinding a Women's Resource Center job offer over a background-check charge. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Should universities be able to reject job applicants over past protest-related arrests?

Nic Francisco-Kaho'onei filed a federal civil rights lawsuit against University of Oregon officials in U.S. District Court in Eugene. The plaintiff alleges the university violated First Amendment rights to free speech and protest after rescinding a program director offer.

Why it matters

The suit tests how public universities weigh past arrests and pending misdemeanor charges in hiring decisions, and whether protest-related conduct can factor into employment outcomes. The university says it acted on charges appearing in a background check and did not want to wait for adjudication.

The lawsuit was filed in U.S. District Court in Eugene and is at the pleading stage, with the plaintiff represented by the Civil Liberties Defense Center. The plaintiff says the Nov. 27, 2024 adjudication of the misdemeanor charge is the basis for requesting reconsideration, but no court has ruled on the claims.

The players

University of Oregon

A public research university in Eugene, Oregon, whose officials are named as defendants in the lawsuit over the rescinded job offer.

Mark Schmelz

A University of Oregon official named as a defendant, who announced his departure from the university on Nov. 10, 2026 to become vice president and chief human resources officer at Cornell University.

The details

Francisco-Kaho'onei was offered the program director position at the UO Women's Resource Center in November 2024 after being arrested in April 2024 for disorderly conduct. The university rescinded the offer after background-check charges surfaced, and the plaintiff asked the university in a letter to reconsider once the charges were adjudicated.

Timeline

  1. April 2024: Francisco-Kaho'onei arrested for disorderly conduct during a protest.

  2. August 2024: Francisco-Kaho'onei applies for the position.

  3. November 2024: Francisco-Kaho'onei offered the program director job.

  4. Dec. 4, 2024: University informs plaintiff the offer is rescinded.

  5. Nov. 19, 2026: Lawsuit filed in U.S. District Court in Eugene.

Legal Context

The case sits within the body of First Amendment law governing public employers, which restricts government employers from penalizing employees or applicants for protected protest activity. Whether a pending misdemeanor and past arrest can justify withdrawing a job offer will turn on how courts weigh those protections against an employer's interest in background screening.

Applicants with past arrests or pending charges at public institutions may face uncertainty about how background-check findings will be used in hiring. The case could clarify whether protest-related conduct can be considered in employment decisions.

The takeaway

Job applicants whose background checks show pending charges should understand that hiring decisions can change before charges are resolved. The outcome of this suit may shape how public employers handle similar situations.

Further reading

Follow more Law coverage for context on legal disputes like this one in Eugene.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Daily Emerald.

Live Poll

Should universities be able to reject job applicants over past protest-related arrests?