Oregon Court Expands Insurer Fee Liability

Appeals court says a good-faith claim against an insurer can qualify for attorney fees, sending a $40,000 award back for review.

Updated on Nov. 19, 2026 in Insurance

Oregon Court Expands Insurer Fee Liability

Live Poll

Do you trust insurance companies to treat customers fairly when claims are denied?

The Oregon Court of Appeals ruled on November 18, 2026, in Precy Conry v. Standard Fire Insurance Company that a breach of the duty of good faith and fair dealing claim against an insurer can qualify for attorney fees. The court reversed and remanded a $40,000 fee award from Multnomah County Circuit Court for reconsideration.

Why it matters

The ruling extends fee eligibility under Oregon statute ORS 742.061(1) to good-faith claims, which the court said are longstanding common-law obligations in insurance contracts. For Oregon policyholders, it may affect how insurers face litigation over claim handling.

Plaintiff sought $162,694.50 in attorney fees, and the trial court awarded $40,000 on the breach-of-contract claim only. The three claims settled for $36,500, excluding fees and costs, and the remanded award will be recalculated.

The players

Standard Fire Insurance Company

The insurer named in the case is part of Travelers Group and was the defendant over coverage of Conry's medical expenses.

Travelers Group

A large American insurance company that is the parent of Standard Fire Insurance Company.

The details

Conry was a passenger in a car accident and was covered under the driver's Standard Fire policy, but the insurer did not cover her full medical expenses. The appeals court found the good-faith-and-fair-dealing claim should also be treated as fee-eligible, and Judge Celia A. Howes of Multnomah County Circuit Court had limited fees to the contract claim.

Timeline

  1. November 18, 2026: Oregon Court of Appeals issued the ruling reversing and remanding the fee award.

Market Dynamics

The decision extends the fee-shifting provision of ORS 742.061(1) to good-faith claims against insurers, a change in how Oregon's insurance statute applies to contract disputes. It places the ruling within the state's existing framework for holding insurers accountable in policy litigation.

Oregon policyholders who pursue good-faith claims against insurers may now have a path to recover attorney fees that was previously limited to contract claims. The ruling does not change the $40,000 figure until the trial court completes its recalculation on remand.

The takeaway

Policyholders in Oregon should note that bad-faith claims against insurers may carry fee-recovery rights alongside contract claims. Reviewing how a claim is categorized early can affect the attorney fees available if a dispute goes to court.

Further reading

For more on how state rules shape policyholder disputes, see Insurance coverage in Oregon.

Source note: This article includes information reported by Daily Tidings.

Live Poll

Do you trust insurance companies to treat customers fairly when claims are denied?