Danny Kanell Named John Mateer Biggest Disappointment

The Oklahoma quarterback has struggled to meet high expectations during the 2026 season.

Updated on Oct. 9, 2026 in Football

Danny Kanell Named John Mateer Biggest Disappointment

Live Poll

Is it fair to label college athletes as disappointments based on preseason performance expectations?

Analyst Danny Kanell has identified Oklahoma starting quarterback John Mateer as the biggest disappointment in college football this year. Mateer’s struggles have been highlighted by turnovers that hampered the team in losses to Michigan and Georgia.

Why it matters

The quarterback's inability to match preseason expectations has stalled an offense that otherwise benefits from a top-five defense. Managing the pressure of the position remains a critical challenge for the team as they prepare for high-stakes competition.

John Mateer has recorded 883 passing yards and 8 touchdowns against 4 interceptions, while maintaining a 56.7 QBR that ranks 69th among players. He has also added 76 rushing yards on 41 carries with 0 rushing touchdowns this season.

The players

Danny Kanell

A college football analyst who previously played the quarterback position at Florida State from 1992 to 1995.

John Mateer

The current starting quarterback for the Oklahoma Sooners who is navigating a difficult 2-2 start to the season.

The details

Mateer has struggled to lead the 2-2 Sooners, with turnovers proving particularly costly in matchups against Georgia and Michigan. The offense continues to lean heavily on its top-five defensive unit while the quarterback adjusts to the demands of the starting role.

1992-1995: Danny Kanell played quarterback at Florida State.
September 2026: John Mateer performed poorly as quarterback.
October 10, 2026: Oklahoma plays Texas in the Red River Rivalry.

Season Trajectory

The criticism of Mateer highlights the immense pressure facing the Sooners ahead of their pivotal clash with Texas in the Red River Rivalry. A victory in this matchup is essential for shifting the team's trajectory after a 2-2 start to the season.

Mateer currently holds a 56.7 QBR, which places him 69th nationally and signifies a lack of efficiency in the passing game. Fans and analysts will be watching his turnover rate closely as the Sooners seek to improve upon their 2-2 record in the upcoming Red River Rivalry.

The takeaway

Quarterbacks often carry the burden of preseason hype, making consistent decision-making under pressure the most vital skill for long-term success. Maintaining focus on fundamental ball security can help struggling players regain their rhythm during intense conference schedules.