Judge Dismisses Suit Against Probate Judge Puffenberger

A visiting judge threw out a civil case alleging taxpayer money was used to boost a judicial candidate's campaign.

Updated on Nov. 18, 2026 in Politics

Bold flat-color editorial illustration of a limestone civic facade with a central flagpole and a bronze ballot-box silhouette in deep red and cream, evoking public funds and elections.
A visiting judge dismissed a civil suit on November 17, 2026, alleging Lucas County Probate Judge Jack Puffenberger used taxpayer money to boost his son Tom Puffenberger's judicial campaign. AI Illustration. Upload story photo >

Live Poll

Do you trust local government officials to keep taxpayer-funded ads separate from their family's campaigns?

A visiting judge dismissed a civil suit naming Lucas County Probate Judge Jack Puffenberger as defendant. The suit alleged he used taxpayer money to boost his son Tom Puffenberger's judicial campaign.

Why it matters

The ruling addresses whether government-funded public service announcements that did not use a candidate's first name can unfairly benefit a relative on the ballot. Tom Puffenberger went on to win the Lucas County Probate Court race.

The ads at issue aired in 2025 and did not use Jack Puffenberger's first name, according to the case record. The visiting judge's ruling that the ads are public service announcements rested on the content of the messages rather than their cost, which was not reported.

The players

Jack Puffenberger

Jack Puffenberger is the Lucas County Probate Judge who was named as defendant in the civil suit over alleged use of taxpayer money in a campaign.

Tom Puffenberger

Tom Puffenberger is a Lucas County attorney who won the Lucas County Probate Court judicial race.

David Karmol

David Karmol is a Ohio state representative candidate who alleged the ads unfairly benefited the judge's son and who lost his state representative race.

The details

David Karmol, a state representative candidate, alleged that ads aired by Judge Puffenberger unfairly benefited his son. The visiting judge ruled the ads may or may not indirectly benefit anyone with the same name as the defendant, and dismissed the case on November 17, 2026.

Timeline

  1. 2025: Ads at issue aired during the Lucas County Probate Court campaign.

  2. November 17, 2026: Visiting judge dismissed the civil suit.

Legal Context

The dismissal falls under Ohio's existing framework limiting government officials from using public resources to influence elections, a framework that courts have applied case by case. This ruling places public service announcements that avoid naming a candidate outside the reach of that framework when the same surname appears on the ballot.

Voters in Lucas County may see government-funded public service announcements from officials who are on the ballot or related to candidates. The ruling means such ads that avoid a candidate's first name are not automatically treated as campaign spending.

The takeaway

Ads paid for by taxpayers can still raise election concerns even when they avoid naming a candidate, especially when a relative is running. Readers following local races can check how such messages are funded and framed.

Further reading

For more on the courts and election law, see Law coverage.

Source note: This article includes information reported by 13abc.

Live Poll

Do you trust local government officials to keep taxpayer-funded ads separate from their family's campaigns?