Ohio Commission Dismisses Claim Against Ex-Lorain Chief
The Ohio Civil Rights Commission dismissed a complaint filed by Lt. Corey Middlebrooks against retired Lorain Police Chief James McCann.
Updated on Nov. 17, 2026 in Law Enforcement

Live Poll
Do you trust your local government to handle discrimination complaints fairly?
The Ohio Civil Rights Commission issued a letter of determination dismissing a civil rights complaint filed by Lt. Corey Middlebrooks against retired Lorain Police Chief James McCann. The commission also found Middlebrooks was subjected to discriminatory retaliation regarding his termination by the City of Lorain.
Why it matters
The ruling clears McCann of the complaint while finding retaliation tied to the city's termination of Middlebrooks, a finding that bears on how disciplinary decisions within the Lorain Police Department are handled. For Lorain residents, it highlights the city's exposure to retaliation findings involving its police leadership.
The commission's investigation considered documents and testimony before issuing the determination dismissing the claim against McCann. The claim against the City of Lorain's termination decision resulted in a retaliation finding, and any further proceedings were not described.
The players
James McCann
Retired Lorain Police Chief who was named in the civil rights complaint and whose claim was dismissed by the Ohio Civil Rights Commission.
City of Lorain
The Ohio city whose termination of Lt. Corey Middlebrooks the commission found to be discriminatory retaliation.
The details
McCann recommended Middlebrooks' demotion from captain to lieutenant after a third-party evaluation of his performance, and he provided observations as chief during the disciplinary hearing and an internal investigation. Safety Service Director Rey Carrion made the decision to terminate Middlebrooks following a recommendation from the department's Office of Professional Standards and Acting Chief of Police James Oliver.
Timeline
The demotion and termination dates were not specified in the report.
The Morning Journal published its report on the dismissal on November 17, 2026.
Legal Context
Ohio's civil rights complaint process, administered by the Ohio Civil Rights Commission, is the state venue for employment discrimination and retaliation claims against public employers. This determination split the outcome, dismissing the claim against an individual official while finding retaliation by the city.
Lorain residents may see the city's handling of police discipline and retaliation claims shape oversight of their local department. The finding against the city may affect how future personnel decisions by the police department are reviewed.
The takeaway
Civil rights determinations can separate individual accountability from institutional liability, as this case did by dismissing the claim against McCann while finding retaliation by the city. Readers following local government should watch how such findings influence department discipline procedures.
Further reading
Explore more Law Enforcement coverage from across Lorain.
Source note: This article includes information reported by Morning Journal.
Live Poll
Do you trust your local government to handle discrimination complaints fairly?






